assets/evals/fixtures/winloss/transcript.txt
1 Interviewer: Thanks for making time. We're doing a short deal debrief — want to understand what ended up mattering. 2 Client: Sure, no problem, I've just got maybe forty minutes, then I've got a meeting. 3 Interviewer: We'll make it work. Let's start from the beginning: how did the need to choose a warehouse management system even come up? 4 Client: Well, look, our warehouse in Kashira was growing, three sites already. 5 Client: The old setup was Excel plus some custom thing built by a developer who left in March. 6 Client: Basically it became clear we couldn't keep going like that, but nobody got around to it for six months, and then the CEO said — okay, that's it, we're looking for a system. 7 Interviewer: And you went out to look at solutions on the market. Who did you actually talk to, besides us? 8 Client: We looked at three options. You, Stackly. 9 Client: Then LogiCore — they're the ones known for the CRM module, they've also got industry case studies in distribution. 10 Client: And one more totally local outfit, forgot the name, but that fell through right away on price, they turned out too expensive for us. 11 Interviewer: So in the end the finalists were us and LogiCore? 12 Client: Yeah, the finalists were you and LogiCore, we filtered out the third one already at the call stage, about two weeks in. 13 Interviewer: Did you consider just not changing anything at all? 14 Client: We discussed it, honestly, the CEO first said let's just grind through another year on the old system. 15 Client: But after we lost a shipment twice in April because of confusion in the stock counts, everyone agreed we couldn't keep dragging it out. 16 Interviewer: Okay. What criteria did you actually compare on, what mattered to you? 17 Client: Well, price, of course, can't get around that. 18 Client: Functionality for product labeling — that's critical for us, the mandatory labeling requirement and all that. 19 Client: Also support, because we'd already gotten burned when tech support didn't answer for three days straight on the previous system. 20 Client: And also, why hide it, reputation — who these vendors even are, who recommended them, whether there are case studies in our industry. 21 Interviewer: On each of these points — how did we and LogiCore look? 22 Client: On price you were about fifteen percent cheaper, that was nice, not gonna lie. 23 Client: On labeling, LogiCore had it right out of the box, but with you it needed custom dev work, you said so yourselves, three to four weeks. 24 Interviewer: What about support? 25 Client: Now this part came out funny. 26 Client: On your demo, the engineer straight up couldn't answer a question about 1C integration on the spot, said he'd check and get back. 27 Client: And at LogiCore they had an architect right there on the call, laid out everything step by step. 28 Interviewer: And on reputation? 29 Client: About even there, honestly, both vendors sent us three references each early on, we didn't even call all of them, no time. 30 Interviewer: Let's talk about the sales process itself. How did getting to know us go, and LogiCore? 31 Client: You responded fast, literally the day after we submitted the request, that's a plus. 32 Client: The demo was four days later. 33 Client: LogiCore took a bit longer getting going, we waited about three days for the manager to respond, but when they came — it was straight away with a ready-made scenario built for our profile, for distribution, not a generic template. 34 Interviewer: So their demo was more targeted? 35 Client: Yeah, exactly. It was like they already knew we had three warehouses and the labeling requirement. 36 Client: And your manager on the first call was asking general stuff, like starting from zero, we had to explain everything all over again. 37 Interviewer: Tell me, was there a specific moment, a conversation, a demo, after which it became clear which way things were leaning? 38 Client: Well, it's funny, but yeah. 39 Client: It was at the second demo with LogiCore, about three weeks after we started. 40 Client: Their architect, right in front of our logistics director, spun up a live test environment in real time and showed goods receiving with labeling, the whole cycle, in about ten minutes. 41 Client: And right in that moment our logistics director turned to the CFO and said: look, this is exactly what we need, no song and dance. 42 Interviewer: Did we have anything similar? 43 Client: You also had a demo, but it was more of a talk about the system architecture, slides, a product roadmap. 44 Client: Also decent, honestly, but not as hands-on. 45 Client: Maybe if you'd also spun up a live environment — I don't know, maybe things would've gone differently, it's hard to say for sure, that's just me guessing at this point. 46 Interviewer: Who actually made the decision in the end, who was involved? 47 Client: Formally the decision is mine, I'm the procurement director. 48 Client: But in practice everyone listened hard to the logistics director, he's the one who'll be working with the system every day, his word carried a lot of weight. 49 Client: The CFO also looked at the numbers, but he was more signing off than deciding. 50 Client: The CEO delegated it pretty much entirely, asked only once — is the vendor reliable at all, won't they go under in a year. 51 Interviewer: And whose opinion turned out to be decisive? 52 Client: Honestly, the logistics director's. 53 Client: After that demo with the receiving process he flat out said: I'm for LogiCore, and that was that, after that we were just finalizing paperwork. 54 Interviewer: Look, the CFO was watching the numbers — am I right that price still wasn't the last factor? 55 Client: Price was a factor, but not the decisive one. 56 Client: LogiCore's price, by the way, was higher than yours by about twelve to fifteen percent, but we agreed to it. 57 Client: Because we figured the custom work on your labeling would eat up that difference through downtime and audit risk. 58 Interviewer: So you overpaid on purpose? 59 Client: Yeah, we overpaid for the functionality already being ready and not having to wait for custom dev, for us that was worth more than the money saved. 60 Interviewer: If our labeling had also been out of the box at demo time, would the decision have been different? 61 Client: Probably yes, most likely yes, I think LogiCore wouldn't have won so clearly then. 62 Client: But again, that's all hindsight guessing, hard to say for sure, other things could've played out differently too back then. 63 Interviewer: Okay, and if we're being completely honest — name the main reason you ended up not choosing us? 64 Client: Well, for the record — let's put it this way, LogiCore turned out to have a more mature product for our profile at the time of the decision, ready-made labeling, industry experience with distribution. 65 Client: Nothing personal, your product was just half a step behind specifically on that feature. 66 Interviewer: And off the record? 67 Client: Well, between us — off the record, honestly, I feel like it wasn't only about the labeling. 68 Client: Our logistics director spent two years before this working at a company that was already running on LogiCore, he had a contact there he knew personally. 69 Client: He called him, asked how it actually works in real life, not on a demo, and got the answer that it's fine, stable. 70 Client: That trust through someone he knew, I think, really tipped the scales, and the labeling — that's more like a nice, presentable justification for the board. 71 Interviewer: So the official reason and the real one are a bit different things? 72 Client: There's something to that, yeah. 73 Client: Officially — functionality. 74 Client: But in reality, probably around sixty percent of it was personal trust plus that impressive demo with the live environment. 75 Client: But I don't want it to sound like the product had nothing to do with it at all, the labeling really was a weak spot. 76 Interviewer: Would you be able to come back to us in the future if something changes? 77 Client: Look, the contract with LogiCore is for two years. 78 Client: But if you get ready-made labeling and make noise about it in the market, I wouldn't rule out that in a year or a year and a half we'd take another look. 79 Client: Especially if LogiCore starts running into its own problems, which happens. 80 Interviewer: Is everything going smoothly with LogiCore right now, at the start of implementation? 81 Client: So far yes, but implementation only starts in two weeks, too early to say. 82 Client: Sometimes after signing a completely different story starts than what was shown at the demo, so I won't try to predict it ahead of time. 83 Interviewer: What would you recommend we change going forward, to win deals like this? 84 Client: In your position I'd show a live environment with labeling right away at the demo for distribution clients, not slides with a roadmap. 85 Client: And make sure there's a technical person right there at the demo who can answer about integrations, instead of pushing it to later. 86 Interviewer: Anything else important we didn't ask about? 87 Client: Maybe just this — I wouldn't say it was an easy win for LogiCore. 88 Client: There was actually a moment when our CFO almost swung everything back toward you because of price, literally a week before the final decision, but the demo with the live environment still won out in the end. 89 Client: So don't be too discouraged, you were genuinely close. 90 Interviewer: Thank you so much, this is very helpful. 91 Client: You're welcome, good luck to you, it really was a good product, just not this time.