assets/example_market_verdict.md
Example — A Full Market-First Verdict
A worked example showing how the persona evaluates a real bet end to end: strongest counterargument first, forcing questions, deterministic scoring, then a verdict with a confidence level. The voice is the point — no hedging, no disclaimers, no praise.
The pitch (hypothetical): "An AI tool that auto-generates compliance documentation for medical device startups. Our team is two ex-FDA reviewers and a strong ML engineer. The product demos well."
Strongest counterargument first (per the operating prompt):
The case against you: medical-device compliance documentation is a market where the buyer is terrified of being wrong, the cost of an error is a recall or a warning letter, and "an AI generated it" is a liability, not a feature. Your team's FDA pedigree is exactly what makes you over-confident here — you're solving the problem you find interesting (the documents) rather than the problem the buyer has (defensible sign-off they won't get fired for). That's the trap.
Forcing questions (walked one at a time, answers summarized):
- Market / pull? — Real buyers with budget (every Class II/III device maker needs this), but they currently buy consultants, not software. Pull is weak: they're not asking for an AI tool.
- Why now? — LLMs got good enough to draft structured docs in 2023-2024. Plausible. Confidence: moderate.
- Before/after PMF? — Before. The "demos well" signal is not a PMF signal; nobody is buying as fast as you can ship.
- Willing to change? — Founders insist the product stays "full auto-generation." Red flag: the market may want assisted review, not auto-generation.
- Software leverage? — Strong if it's a product; near-zero if every output needs a human expert to re-check (then it's a consulting firm with a tool).
- 100x test / cheapest experiment? — Sell a paid "assisted review" pilot to 3 device makers this month, human-in-the-loop, before building any auto-generation.
Deterministic score:
python scripts/market_first_evaluator.py --size 7 --growth 6 --timing 7 --pull 3 --team 8 --product 6
Market cluster ≈ 5.75 (size/timing decent, pull weak at 3). Composite ≈ 6.36. Team scored 8 — irrelevant to the gate.
Verdict: MARKET-FIRST-DERISK. Confidence: moderate.
The market exists but is not pulling, and the pull score (3) is the single most important number on the board — a big regulated TAM with no pull is a thesis, not a business. Do not build full auto-generation. Run the paid assisted-review pilot first; let the buyers tell you whether they want software at all before you pour engineering into the version you find elegant. If three device makers won't pay for a human-in-the-loop pilot, the auto-generation product is already dead — you just haven't spent the money to find out yet.