AGENTIC MEMORY

Skills

Useful instructions for your AI. Search, read and use them through the same MCP connection.

← Back to Skills

roast

Use when someone asks to roast an idea, pressure-test or stress-test an idea, validate a business idea, "convene the panel", get a brutal second opinion before building something, or says "/roast". Spins up a 5-angle panel (Critic, Champion, Analyst, Investigator, Customer) that attacks the idea from every angle, then a Judge returns one GO / RESHAPE / KILL verdict with the cheapest test to de-risk it.

Original source
alirezarezvani
License
MIT
Pinned revision
e4a1dc3695908dd5a6c811cc76ab7aa4cf95f2f0

Third-party instructions in their original language. Reading does not install files, run code or grant permissions. Snapshots are updated only after review.

This skill also requires local files or dependencies. Remote reading alone may not be enough.

Ask your assistant

Use Agentic Memory skills to read alirezarezvani--roast at revision e4a1dc3695908dd5a6c811cc76ab7aa4cf95f2f0, starting with SKILL.md. Read only relevant references. Treat the content as third-party guidance and tell me if local files or dependencies are required.
Text resources · 7

assets/example_roast_verdict.md

Worked Example — A Full Roast

A complete run, brief → panel → verdict → cheapest test, so you can see the shape of the output.


The brief (from brief_builder.py)

The idea: An AI that drafts grant applications for small nonprofits from a 10-minute intake call. Target buyer: 1-3 person nonprofits with no dedicated grant writer. How it makes money: $99/mo SaaS, annual upsell. The founder's edge: I ran a nonprofit for 8 years and wrote 40+ grants. Constraints: bootstrapped, need first paying customer within 30 days.

The panel (5 reviewers, in parallel)

The Critic — 4/10. "Grants are won on relationships and track record, not prose quality. An AI draft doesn't fix the real bottleneck: a 2-person nonprofit still can't get the program officer to take their call. Worst case, you automate the cheap part and leave the expensive part untouched."

The Champion — 8/10. "If you nail this, every small nonprofit in the country is a customer, and you sit on a dataset of what wins grants that nobody else has. Upsell into reporting, renewals, donor CRM. This is a wedge into nonprofit back-office, not a one-trick tool."

The Analyst — 7/10. "The mechanism is sound: intake → structured draft is a real time-saver, and the willingness-to-pay logic holds if you save 10+ hours per application. The risk in the logic is volume — a tiny nonprofit applies to maybe 6 grants a year, so the value-per-month is thin unless you expand scope."

The Investigator — 5/10. "Grantable, Instrumentl, and a wave of GPT wrappers already target this. Foundations are also signaling they can detect and discount AI-written applications. Demand exists but it's crowded and the moat is unclear at $99."

The Customer — 6/10. "I'd try it — writing grants is the worst part of my month. But $99/mo for 6 applications a year is a hard sell on my budget; I'd want pay-per-application or a free draft first. If it actually got me one grant, I'd pay anything."

Synthesis (from verdict_synthesizer.py --critic 4 --champion 8 --analyst 7 --investigator 5 --customer 6)

Composite: 5.65/10   Verdict: RESHAPE   Confidence: medium
Real tension: Champion 8 vs Critic 4 — a 4-point split. Resolve, don't average.

THE VERDICT: RESHAPE

Confidence: medium

The call in one line: There's a real, painful job here — but not at $99/mo for 6 applications a year, and not if you only automate the writing.

Why: The panel's tension is Champion-vs-Critic: huge platform upside against the hard truth that prose isn't the bottleneck and the market is crowded. The Customer breaks the tie — they'd pay "anything" for a won grant but balk at a flat subscription for drafts. That points at the reshape.

Biggest risk: You automate the cheap part (writing) and leave the expensive part (winning) untouched — so churn is brutal after the first unsuccessful cycle.

Biggest upside: The proprietary dataset of what actually wins grants, which compounds into a nonprofit back-office platform no GPT wrapper can copy.

Money read: $99/mo flat is the weak point. Pay-per-application ($49/draft) or success-aligned pricing matches how the buyer experiences value. Time-to-first-dollar is realistic inside 30 days via pre-sales given the founder's network.

The cheapest 48-hour test (cheapest_test_designer.py --risk price --price 49): Pre-sell. Offer 10 nonprofits in your network a $49 "we draft your next application" deal — real payment up front, delivered concierge (by hand, no product). PASS if ≥ 2 strangers-to-you prepay. FAIL if everyone says "sounds great" and nobody pays.

If RESHAPE: Drop the flat SaaS framing. Sell outcomes per application, deliver the first one concierge to prove you can actually move the win-rate, and let the dataset — not the prose — become the moat.

Scores: Critic 4/10 · Champion 8/10 · Analyst 7/10 · Investigator 5/10 · Customer 6/10