assets/example_roast_verdict.md
Worked Example — A Full Roast
A complete run, brief → panel → verdict → cheapest test, so you can see the shape of the output.
The brief (from brief_builder.py)
The idea: An AI that drafts grant applications for small nonprofits from a 10-minute intake call. Target buyer: 1-3 person nonprofits with no dedicated grant writer. How it makes money: $99/mo SaaS, annual upsell. The founder's edge: I ran a nonprofit for 8 years and wrote 40+ grants. Constraints: bootstrapped, need first paying customer within 30 days.
The panel (5 reviewers, in parallel)
The Critic — 4/10. "Grants are won on relationships and track record, not prose quality. An AI draft doesn't fix the real bottleneck: a 2-person nonprofit still can't get the program officer to take their call. Worst case, you automate the cheap part and leave the expensive part untouched."
The Champion — 8/10. "If you nail this, every small nonprofit in the country is a customer, and you sit on a dataset of what wins grants that nobody else has. Upsell into reporting, renewals, donor CRM. This is a wedge into nonprofit back-office, not a one-trick tool."
The Analyst — 7/10. "The mechanism is sound: intake → structured draft is a real time-saver, and the willingness-to-pay logic holds if you save 10+ hours per application. The risk in the logic is volume — a tiny nonprofit applies to maybe 6 grants a year, so the value-per-month is thin unless you expand scope."
The Investigator — 5/10. "Grantable, Instrumentl, and a wave of GPT wrappers already target this. Foundations are also signaling they can detect and discount AI-written applications. Demand exists but it's crowded and the moat is unclear at $99."
The Customer — 6/10. "I'd try it — writing grants is the worst part of my month. But $99/mo for 6 applications a year is a hard sell on my budget; I'd want pay-per-application or a free draft first. If it actually got me one grant, I'd pay anything."
Synthesis (from verdict_synthesizer.py --critic 4 --champion 8 --analyst 7 --investigator 5 --customer 6)
Composite: 5.65/10 Verdict: RESHAPE Confidence: medium
Real tension: Champion 8 vs Critic 4 — a 4-point split. Resolve, don't average.
THE VERDICT: RESHAPE
Confidence: medium
The call in one line: There's a real, painful job here — but not at $99/mo for 6 applications a year, and not if you only automate the writing.
Why: The panel's tension is Champion-vs-Critic: huge platform upside against the hard truth that prose isn't the bottleneck and the market is crowded. The Customer breaks the tie — they'd pay "anything" for a won grant but balk at a flat subscription for drafts. That points at the reshape.
Biggest risk: You automate the cheap part (writing) and leave the expensive part (winning) untouched — so churn is brutal after the first unsuccessful cycle.
Biggest upside: The proprietary dataset of what actually wins grants, which compounds into a nonprofit back-office platform no GPT wrapper can copy.
Money read: $99/mo flat is the weak point. Pay-per-application ($49/draft) or success-aligned pricing matches how the buyer experiences value. Time-to-first-dollar is realistic inside 30 days via pre-sales given the founder's network.
The cheapest 48-hour test (cheapest_test_designer.py --risk price --price 49): Pre-sell. Offer
10 nonprofits in your network a $49 "we draft your next application" deal — real payment up front,
delivered concierge (by hand, no product). PASS if ≥ 2 strangers-to-you prepay. FAIL if everyone
says "sounds great" and nobody pays.
If RESHAPE: Drop the flat SaaS framing. Sell outcomes per application, deliver the first one concierge to prove you can actually move the win-rate, and let the dataset — not the prose — become the moat.
Scores: Critic 4/10 · Champion 8/10 · Analyst 7/10 · Investigator 5/10 · Customer 6/10