assets/poc_scorecard_template.md
POC Evaluation Scorecard
Scorecard Information
| Field | Value | |-------|-------| | POC Name | [POC Name] | | Customer | [Customer Name] | | Vendor/Product | [Product Name] | | Evaluation Period | [Start Date] - [End Date] | | Evaluated By | [Names and Roles] | | Date Completed | [Date] |
Scoring Scale
| Score | Label | Definition | |-------|-------|------------| | 5 | Exceeds | Superior capability; exceeds requirements with notable strengths | | 4 | Meets | Full capability; meets all requirements with no significant gaps | | 3 | Partial | Acceptable capability; minor gaps that can be addressed | | 2 | Below | Below expectations; significant gaps that impact value | | 1 | Fails | Does not meet requirements; critical gaps | | N/A | Not Evaluated | Not tested during this POC |
Evaluation Categories
1. Functionality (Weight: 30%)
| Criterion | Score (1-5) | Evidence / Notes | |-----------|-------------|-----------------| | Core feature completeness | | | | Use case coverage | | | | Customization flexibility | | | | Workflow automation | | | | Data handling and transformation | | | | Reporting and analytics | | |
Category Score: ___/5.0 Category Notes: [Summary of functionality evaluation, key strengths and gaps]
2. Performance (Weight: 20%)
| Criterion | Score (1-5) | Evidence / Notes | |-----------|-------------|-----------------| | Response time under expected load | | | | Response time under peak load | | | | Throughput capacity | | | | Scalability characteristics | | | | Resource utilization | | | | Batch processing performance | | |
Category Score: ___/5.0 Category Notes: [Summary of performance evaluation, benchmark results]
3. Integration (Weight: 20%)
| Criterion | Score (1-5) | Evidence / Notes | |-----------|-------------|-----------------| | API completeness and documentation | | | | Data migration ease | | | | Third-party connector availability | | | | Authentication/SSO integration | | | | Real-time sync reliability | | | | Error handling and recovery | | |
Category Score: ___/5.0 Category Notes: [Summary of integration evaluation, systems tested]
4. Usability (Weight: 15%)
| Criterion | Score (1-5) | Evidence / Notes | |-----------|-------------|-----------------| | User interface intuitiveness | | | | Learning curve assessment | | | | Documentation quality | | | | Admin console functionality | | | | Mobile experience | | | | Accessibility compliance | | |
Category Score: ___/5.0 Category Notes: [Summary of usability evaluation, user feedback]
5. Support (Weight: 15%)
| Criterion | Score (1-5) | Evidence / Notes | |-----------|-------------|-----------------| | Technical support responsiveness | | | | Knowledge base quality | | | | Training resources availability | | | | Community and ecosystem | | | | Issue resolution speed | | | | Proactive engagement quality | | |
Category Score: ___/5.0 Category Notes: [Summary of support evaluation during POC]
Score Summary
| Category | Weight | Score | Weighted Score | |----------|--------|-------|----------------| | Functionality | 30% | ___/5.0 | ___ | | Performance | 20% | ___/5.0 | ___ | | Integration | 20% | ___/5.0 | ___ | | Usability | 15% | ___/5.0 | ___ | | Support | 15% | /5.0 | ___ | | Overall | 100% | | **/5.0** |
Decision Thresholds
| Weighted Average | Decision | |-----------------|----------| | >= 4.0 | Strong Pass - Proceed to procurement | | 3.5 - 3.9 | Pass - Proceed with noted conditions | | 3.0 - 3.4 | Conditional - Requires further evaluation | | < 3.0 | Fail - Does not meet requirements |
Success Criteria Results
| # | Criterion | Priority | Target | Actual | Pass/Fail | |---|-----------|----------|--------|--------|-----------| | 1 | [Criterion 1] | Must-Have | [Target] | [Result] | [ ] | | 2 | [Criterion 2] | Must-Have | [Target] | [Result] | [ ] | | 3 | [Criterion 3] | Must-Have | [Target] | [Result] | [ ] | | 4 | [Criterion 4] | Should-Have | [Target] | [Result] | [ ] | | 5 | [Criterion 5] | Should-Have | [Target] | [Result] | [ ] | | 6 | [Criterion 6] | Nice-to-Have | [Target] | [Result] | [ ] |
Must-Have Pass Rate: ___/% Overall Pass Rate: ___/%
Issues Log
| # | Issue | Severity | Status | Resolution | Impact on Score | |---|-------|----------|--------|------------|----------------| | 1 | [Issue] | [Critical/High/Medium/Low] | [Open/Resolved] | [Resolution] | [Category affected] | | 2 | [Issue] | [Critical/High/Medium/Low] | [Open/Resolved] | [Resolution] | [Category affected] |
Stakeholder Feedback
[Stakeholder Name 1] - [Role]
Rating: ___/5 Comments: [Feedback]
[Stakeholder Name 2] - [Role]
Rating: ___/5 Comments: [Feedback]
[Stakeholder Name 3] - [Role]
Rating: ___/5 Comments: [Feedback]
Recommendation
Decision: [ ] GO / [ ] CONDITIONAL GO / [ ] NO-GO
Rationale: [2-3 paragraphs explaining the recommendation based on scorecard results, success criteria outcomes, stakeholder feedback, and overall evaluation]
Conditions (if Conditional GO):
- [Condition 1 that must be met before proceeding]
- [Condition 2 that must be met before proceeding]
Key Strengths:
- [Strength 1]
- [Strength 2]
- [Strength 3]
Key Concerns:
- [Concern 1 with proposed mitigation]
- [Concern 2 with proposed mitigation]
Next Steps:
- [Action item] - [Owner] - [Date]
- [Action item] - [Owner] - [Date]
- [Action item] - [Owner] - [Date]
Sign-Off
| Role | Name | Signature | Date | |------|------|-----------|------| | Technical Evaluator | | | | | Business Sponsor | | | | | Decision Maker | | | | | Sales Engineer | | | |