assets/roast_brief_worksheet.md
Roast Brief Worksheet
Fill this in before convening the panel. All five reviewers judge the same brief, so vagueness here becomes noise in the verdict. Keep each answer tight — one or two sentences.
Tip: run
scripts/brief_builder.pywith these fields to get a normalized paragraph + a check for anything still missing.
1. The idea — what it is and what it does, in one or two sentences.
2. Who it's for — the exact target buyer (be specific: "1-3 person nonprofits with no grant writer," not "nonprofits").
3. How it makes money — price + model (e.g. "$99/mo SaaS," "20% take rate," "one-time $499").
4. Your edge — the relevant skill, audience, or asset you already have that most people don't.
5. Constraints (optional but recommended) — budget, timeline, how fast you need first dollar.
Assembled brief (paste into all five panelists)
The idea: ____. Target buyer: ____. How it makes money: ____. The founder's edge: ____. Constraints: ____.
The five seats (what each one will do to this brief)
| Seat | The question it answers | |---|---| | The Critic | "What kills this?" — fatal flaws, fastest way it dies | | The Champion | "What's the 10x upside?" — biggest case for it | | The Analyst | "Does the logic actually hold?" — first principles, no web | | The Investigator | "What does the real market say?" — web evidence, competitors | | The Customer | "Would I actually pay?" — first-person target buyer |