examples/hard-money-fund/output.md
Deal Analysis — Hard-money bridge fund (well-disclosed)
Produced by the passive-deal-screener skill from the deal in input.md. Illustrative example; figures route to the references/ files, not memory.
Verdict: Pursue. This is a well-disclosed senior-secured bridge fund. It answers the questions that sink most hard-money pitches: LTV on as-is value, default and recovery rates through 2020 and 2022–23, geographic mix, and a fee step-down. Its 9% net target is inside the 8–10% category norm and clears HYG plus the illiquidity hurdle for a 3–5 year lock-up. No RED flags fired. The biggest swing factor is loss severity in the next downturn: whether the 92% recovery holds if defaults double or triple. The open items (performance fee, servicing fee, fund leverage, GP co-invest, realized net-to-LP history, liquidity terms) are confirmations to close in diligence. None of them is a reason to stop.
Screening output only, not investment advice.
1. Deal Snapshot
| Field | Value | Tag |
|---|---|---|
| Asset class | Hard Money / Bridge Loan | 🟢 |
| Deal type | Debt fund, senior secured bridge loans | 🟢 |
| Sponsor | Not stated | — |
| Geography | 12 states; no single metro >15% | 🟢 |
| Minimum investment | Not stated | — |
| Hold / fund term | Not stated. Category norm is 6–18 months per loan and a 3–5 year fund commitment (01). An investment period is mentioned, which implies a closed-end structure. | 🟡 |
| Raise / fund size | Not stated | — |
| Claimed return | 9% net target to LPs | 🟢 |
| Portfolio LTV | 68% as-is / 72% ARV | 🟢 |
| Credit history | 3.1% default rate, 92% realized recovery, including 2020 and 2022–23 | 🟢 |
| Loan grading | A–D, with the grade mix disclosed (the mix itself was not in the pasted text) | 🟢 / 🔴 contents |
| Fees | 1.5% management fee, stepping down to 1.0% after the investment period | 🟢 |
2. Return Stress-Test
The comparator is HYG (4.83% 10yr) plus the duration-matched Treasury (3mo 4.24%, 2yr 4.87%) (05). I assumed a 4-year lock-up (the midpoint of 01's 3–5 year fund norm) because the term is not stated. 🔴
| Case | Net to LP | Swing assumptions | Over HYG | Over 3mo T-bill | vs ~300–400bps hurdle |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Base | 9.0% (stated target) | Defaults ~3.1% at 92% recovery → loss ≈ 25bps/yr if 3.1% is an annual rate 🟡 | 417bps | 476bps | Clears comfortably |
| Bull | ~9.5% 🟡 | Default interest and late fees accrue to the fund (02); full deployment; no cash drag | ~470bps | ~525bps | Clears |
| Bear | ~7.0% 🟡 | Defaults roughly triple to ~9% and recovery falls to ~80% → loss ≈ 180bps/yr; some cash drag during the workout | 217bps | 276bps | Thin / fails the hurdle |
Swing assumptions, named:
- Loss severity. 92% recovery is the anchor number. It is realized, which is good, but it came from a book with a 3.1% default rate. Recovery rates tend to fall at the same time default rates rise.
- Default frequency by grade. The A–D mix sets how quickly defaults can rise. A book weighted toward C/D loans reaches the bear case faster.
- Rate and deployment path. This is short-duration paper, so coupons reprice as loans roll. A falling-rate environment compresses the 9% faster than it compresses HYG. Idle cash between loans also dilutes returns.
Script output (benchmark_comparator.py): 9.0% net → 417bps over HYG, 4-year hurdle ~300–400bps, CLEARS comfortably. 7.0% net → 217bps, THIN / FAILS. The base case earns the lock-up. It takes a real credit event, not a mild one, to break it. The spread over the 2yr Treasury (4.87%) is ≈413bps in the base case and ≈213bps in the bear case.
This is necessary, not sufficient: dispersion means the median fund underperforms the marketed figure (05).
3. Where LP Returns Come From
- Cash flow: essentially 100%. 🟢 The return is loan coupon plus borrower-paid origination points, received as interest over 6–18 month loans. There is no terminal-value or exit-cap bet, so
GEN-08(exit-dependent IRR) does not apply. - Exit: none in the equity sense. Principal comes back as loans repay.
- Leverage: unknown at the fund level. 🔴 The underlying loans are the fund's asset, and the borrower's equity cushion is the 32% as-is gap. What is not stated is whether the fund itself borrows (a credit line or warehouse facility) to lever a ~7–8% loan yield into 9%. If it does, the financing-story concern (
GEN-07) comes back at the fund level. That is a must-ask (§8), not a fired flag.
Read: this is an income story, not a financing story, unless fund leverage turns out to be material.
4. Fee Stack Summary
| Fee | Disclosed | 02 norm | Read |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fund management fee | 1.5% → 1.0% after the investment period | 1–2% of AUM; a step-down is expected | 🟢 In range. Step-down present, so HML-05 does not fire. |
| Basis of the management fee | Not stated (committed, invested, or AUM) | — | 🔴 Ask. |
| Performance fee / carry | Not stated | 10–20% above a 5–8% hurdle; aggressive if >25% or no hurdle | 🔴 Gap |
| Servicing fee | Not stated | 0.25–0.5% of loan balance, annual; aggressive >1% | 🔴 Gap |
| Origination points (borrower-paid) | Not stated | 1–3 points; <1 means thin yield, >5 is predatory | 🔴 Who keeps the points: the fund or the GP? |
| Late fees / default interest | Not stated | Should go to the fund, not the GP | 🔴 Check for a GP "workout fee" |
| Admin / wind-down | Not stated | 0.1–0.5% admin; 0.5–1% wind-down | 🔴 |
Gross-to-net drag: ≈125–150bps/yr from the disclosed stack. This comes from fee_drag_calculator.py using the 1.5% management fee alone (150bps) and a ~1.25% blended rate across the step-down (125bps). All undisclosed fees were passed as 0, and the 4-year hold is ASSUMED.
Backing out the gross: a 9% net with 150bps of drag implies ≈10.5% gross from the loan book. That sits just below the 11–13% gross that 01 calls common. It could mean the book is priced conservatively. It could also mean fees not yet disclosed sit between gross and net. If the true gross is 11–13%, then 50–400bps of drag is unaccounted for: carry, servicing, or a GP share of points.
The stated net target is the LP's protection here. Confirm that the 9% is net of every layer, and get the full schedule so the drag can be computed rather than inferred. This fires GEN-16 at YELLOW for partial disclosure, not the undisclosed case.
5. Red Flags
RED: none.
YELLOW
GEN-16Partial fee disclosure. The management fee and step-down are disclosed. Carry, servicing, the split of points, and admin are not. The LP exposure is up to several hundred bps of drag between an 11–13% gross and the 9% net that cannot be attributed yet. →Q-FEE-01GEN-11No distribution schedule. A net target with no stated distribution cadence (monthly or quarterly) and no reinvestment election. For a debt fund, the LP's return is the distribution stream, so the cadence matters. →Q-DIST-01
Checked and not fired (cited so the absence is visible):
HML-01: as-is LTV is disclosed (68%).HML-02: 12 states, max metro 15%.HML-03/HML-04: default and recovery rates are both disclosed, through both stress periods.HML-05: the step-down is present.GEN-07,GEN-08: no exit or leverage dependency at the loan level. Fund-level leverage is open (§3).
Open, not fired because deciding them would need a 🔴 assumption; each is routed to a must-ask:
GEN-01(co-invest)GEN-05/GEN-14(realized net-to-LP track record)GEN-06(affiliate servicing / points)CREDIT-01(fund leverage). This ID is outside the routedHML-prefix, but the same mechanism applies to a levered bridge fund.
No cluster. The two YELLOWs are disclosure-completeness items, not a structural pattern.
6. Missing Disclosures
Against 01 (Hard Money essentials) and 02 (hard-money fee inventory):
| Missing | Why it matters | Routed to |
|---|---|---|
| Performance fee / carry, hurdle, catch-up | Largest possible unattributed drag | Q-FEE-01 |
| Servicing fee; who retains origination points, late fees, default interest | GP economics outside the headline fee | Q-FEE-01, Q-FEE-02 |
| Fund-level leverage | Tells you whether 9% is a levered or unlevered yield | Q-RISK-06 |
| Basis of the default rate (annual vs cumulative; by count vs by dollar) and of the recovery rate (principal only or principal plus accrued interest; realized vs pending workouts) | Loss math swings ~4× between readings | Q-RISK-05 |
| Workout timeline on defaulted loans | Time in foreclosure is cash drag even at 92% recovery | Q-RISK-05 |
| LTV basis reconciliation: 68% as-is vs 72% ARV | ARV > as-is value, so LTV on ARV should normally be lower. The likely reason is different numerators: initial advance over as-is value vs total commitment (including rehab holdback) over ARV. Confirm it. 🟡 | Q-RISK-04 |
| Grade mix contents (A–D shares) and default rate by grade | Shows how the book behaves in the bear case | Q-RISK-05 |
| Fund term, redemption / lock-up terms | Lock-up length sets the illiquidity hurdle | Q-LIQ-01 |
| Sponsor identity, GP co-invest, realized net-to-LP history | Alignment and track record (§7) | Q-GP-01, Q-GP-02, Q-GP-03 |
| Minimum, fund size | Snapshot completeness | — |
7. GP Alignment
- Co-invest: not stated. 🔴 Unverified. It is not a fired
GEN-01, but it is a must-ask. - Track record: partially verified. 🟢 on credit metrics: a realized recovery rate through 2020 and 2022–23 is exactly the evidence
01asks for ("sponsor history through a downturn"). That is stronger than most hard-money pitches. Unverified on LP outcome: the 9% is a target. No realized net-to-LP returns by vintage or year were given. Until those arrive, the LP-return record counts as unverified (GEN-14,GEN-05open). - Fee alignment: favorable where disclosed. The step-down after the investment period is the LP-friendly structure. The carry design (hurdle, catch-up, high-water mark) is unknown.
- Affiliate economics: unknown. Servicing and origination points often flow to a GP affiliate. The test is disclosure and benchmarking (
GEN-06).
8. Questions for the GP
Must-ask
| ID | Question (as tailored) | Bad-answer signal |
|---|---|---|
| Q-FEE-01 (GEN-16) | "Provide the complete fee schedule: carry/performance fee and hurdle, servicing, admin, wind-down. Is 9% net of all of it?" | "Standard market fees"; a partial list; "the PPM has it" without producing the PPM. |
| Q-FEE-02 (GEN-06) | "Who services the loans, and who keeps origination points, late fees, and default interest: the fund or a GP affiliate?" | "All arm's-length" without naming the providers; points or default interest flow to the GP undisclosed. |
| Q-RISK-05 (HML-03, HML-04) | "Is 3.1% annual or cumulative, by count or by dollar? Is 92% recovery on principal only, realized, and what is the average workout timeline? Break it out for 2020 and 2022–23, by loan grade." | Default rate without recovery (or vice versa); "we've never had a loss"; vague on 2022–23. |
| Q-RISK-04 (HML-01) | "Reconcile 68% as-is vs 72% ARV. What numerator does each use, and what is as-is LTV on the total commitment including holdbacks?" | Can't produce as-is LTV on the full commitment; "our borrowers always complete." |
| Q-RISK-06 (CREDIT-01, escalated) | "Does the fund use a credit line or other leverage? What ratio, and is the 9% levered?" | Won't give a number; "leverage is conservative"; presents a levered yield as if unlevered. |
| Q-GP-02 (GEN-05, GEN-14) | "Give realized net-to-LP returns by year or vintage, including 2020 and 2022–23." | Only the target, or gross loan yield; can't separate realized from marked. |
| Q-GP-01 (GEN-01) | "How much GP capital is in the fund, on LP terms?" | "Our sweat equity is our investment"; a fee waiver in place of cash. |
| Q-GP-03 (GEN-02) | "Any regulatory action, enforcement, or investor litigation?" | "Nothing material"; a search turns up something they did not disclose. |
| Q-DIST-01 (GEN-11) | "What is the distribution cadence? Is there a reinvestment/DRIP option? When do distributions begin after funding?" | "We'll distribute when the book supports it"; no cadence stated. |
| Q-LIQ-01 | "What is the fund term, and what are the redemption or early-exit options, gates, and penalties?" | "We'll try to accommodate"; lock-up terms not disclosed. |
Nice-to-ask
| ID | Question | Bad-answer signal |
|---|---|---|
| Q-GP-04 (GEN-04) | "How have underwriting and asset-management headcount grown with AUM?" | AUM multiplied while the team stayed flat; no named workout lead. |
| Q-DIST-02 | "Are there capital calls, and what happens on a missed call?" | "As needed," with no notice period. |
| Q-LIQ-02 | "When are K-1s delivered?" | A history of extensions. |
Not asked, because the flags do not apply to a debt fund: Q-DS-01, Q-DS-02 (no exit or cap-rate story at the loan level), Q-EXIT-01, Q-EXIT-02, Q-RISK-01, Q-RISK-02.
9. Diligence Checklist
- [ ] PPM and LPA: confirm the fee schedule, carry mechanics, step-down trigger, leverage limits, redemption terms, and where points and default interest go.
- [ ] Audited fund financials (multi-year): verify the default and recovery figures against the audited loss history, not marketing.
- [ ] Loan tape: grade mix, LTV per loan (as-is and ARV, same numerator), and state/metro exposure, to verify the 15% cap.
- [ ] Sample of defaulted-loan files from 2020 and 2022–23: foreclosure timeline, legal cost, recovery realized vs marked.
- [ ] Valuation process: who sets the as-is and ARV values (independent appraisal vs broker price opinion vs internal).
- [ ] Background check: SEC IAPD / Form ADV, FINRA BrokerCheck, state securities regulators, litigation search on the principals.
- [ ] Fund-level credit facility agreement, if any: covenants, and whether a lender margin call could force loan sales.
- [ ] Reference calls with existing LPs on distribution consistency through 2022–23.
10. Verdict
Pursue. 🟢 on the core story.
Reasoning. The essential hard-money disclosures in 01 are present:
- as-is and ARV LTV
- default rate
- recovery rate
- geographic mix
- history through 2020 and 2022–23
Every hard-money-specific flag (HML-01 through HML-05) checks clean. The return is income, not exit or cap-rate driven. At 9% net it sits mid-range for the category and ≈417bps over HYG, clearing a ~300–400bps hurdle for a 3–5 year lock-up. The 32% as-is equity cushion, combined with a demonstrated 92% realized recovery, is the actual LP protection. It is disclosed rather than asserted. The two YELLOWs (GEN-16, GEN-11) are gaps in disclosure completeness. They are not structural defects.
Biggest swing factor. Loss severity in a true credit event. Defaults tripling with recovery falling to ~80% takes the net to ~7%, which is thin against the hurdle. The grade mix and the default-rate basis (annual vs cumulative) determine how close the book sits to that case.
What would have to be true to commit:
- 9% is net of all fees, and total undisclosed GP economics (carry, servicing, points) are within
02norms. - Fund-level leverage is zero or modest, and 9% is not a levered figure.
- The 3.1% / 92% figures hold up on a dollar-weighted, realized basis in audited financials.
- GP co-invests real cash, and the background check is clean.
Suits: an LP who wants income-oriented, short-duration, senior-secured real-estate credit, can accept a 3–5 year lock-up, and is using this fund as a diversifier against equity-RE holdings. It is not a growth allocation. The return is capped at the coupon, and the downside is credit loss.
Would flip to Pass if:
- undisclosed fees sit between a 12–13% gross and the 9% net with a no-hurdle carry;
- fund leverage exceeds a modest line; or
- the 3.1% default rate turns out to be annual by count while dollar-weighted losses run materially higher.