AGENTIC MEMORY

Skills

Useful instructions for your AI. Search, read and use them through the same MCP connection.

← Back to Skills

passive-deal-screener

Use when a passive investor shares a private deal (syndication, preferred equity, bridge fund, private credit) to screen as an LP. Stress-tests it, computes fee drag with fee_drag_calculator.py and compares terms with benchmark_comparator.py.

Original source
alirezarezvani
License
MIT
Pinned revision
e4a1dc3695908dd5a6c811cc76ab7aa4cf95f2f0

Third-party instructions in their original language. Reading does not install files, run code or grant permissions. Snapshots are updated only after review.

This skill also requires local files or dependencies. Remote reading alone may not be enough.

Ask your assistant

Use Agentic Memory skills to read alirezarezvani--passive-deal-screener at revision e4a1dc3695908dd5a6c811cc76ab7aa4cf95f2f0, starting with SKILL.md. Read only relevant references. Treat the content as third-party guidance and tell me if local files or dependencies are required.
Text resources · 18

references/04-question-bank.md

Question Bank (LP perspective)

The questions an LP should put to a GP before committing capital — each paired with what a good answer sounds like and, more importantly, what a bad answer sounds like. The bad-answer signals are this file's reason to exist: plenty of tools tell you what to ask; the differentiator is naming the specific evasion so an LP can recognize it in real time.

How to read this file

  • Priority is must-ask or nice-to-ask. A must-ask is one where a bad answer is, on its own, a reason to pass or to hard-condition the commitment. A nice-to-ask sharpens the picture but rarely decides the outcome alone. Apply judgment: a nice-to-ask escalates to must-ask when the matching flag from 03 has already fired.
  • The bad-answer signal is the product. A vague "they were evasive" is not useful. Each bad-answer cell names the specific dodge for that question — the redirect, the substituted metric, the silence — so the evasion is identifiable, not just felt.
  • Cross-references point into 03-red-flag-library.md. Most questions are the full-length version of a flag's one-line "Response"; the flag ID is cited. Ask the question because the flag fired; treat a bad answer as the flag confirmed.
  • Conditional questions are marked. Some questions only apply to a deal type or a cycle position (HML/credit debt funds, post-2020 office). They are labeled so the skill asks them only when relevant.
  • No invented thresholds. Numeric triggers (pref <6%, promote >30%, exit-dependent IRR >60%) come from 02/03 or a committed analyst rule; otherwise the question defers to the deal's own underwriting.

Contents

  1. Deal-specific — Q-DS-01–Q-DS-03
  2. GP / sponsor-specific — Q-GP-01–Q-GP-04
  3. Market-specific — Q-MKT-01–Q-MKT-02
  4. Fee / structure-specific — Q-FEE-01–Q-FEE-04
  5. Risk-specific — Q-RISK-01–Q-RISK-06
  6. Exit-specific — Q-EXIT-01–Q-EXIT-02
  7. Distribution timing — Q-DIST-01–Q-DIST-02
  8. LP liquidity / secondary market — Q-LIQ-01–Q-LIQ-02

25 questions across 8 categories. Cross-references span 28 distinct flag IDs from 03-red-flag-library.md.


Deal-specific

Questions that interrogate where the return actually comes from — the core of distinguishing an asset story from a financing story.

| ID | Question | Priority | Good-answer signals | Bad-answer signals | 03 ref | |---|---|---|---|---|---| | Q-DS-01 | "What share of projected LP IRR comes from in-place cash flow versus the exit, and what's the IRR at a flat exit cap?" | Must-ask | A specific split; most return from in-place cash flow; the deal still clears the pref at a flat exit cap. | Can't or won't decompose the IRR; pivots to "real estate always appreciates"; the IRR collapses below pref at a flat exit cap. | GEN-08, EQUITY-06 | | Q-DS-02 | "Strip out leverage and cap-rate compression — what is the unlevered, in-place return?" | Must-ask | Provides an unlevered number; the operational return stands on its own before financing. | Treats the levered IRR as the only relevant figure; no unlevered view exists; "leverage is just how the deal works." | GEN-07 | | Q-DS-03 | "What is the return under a bear case — flat rents, higher exit cap, no refinance?" | Must-ask | A real downside scenario with the three swing assumptions stressed; LP capital survives it. | A single-point pro forma with no downside; "we underwrite conservatively" with nothing to show; the bear case is still a gain. | GEN-13 |

Notes. Q-DS-01 and Q-DS-02 are the same question from two sides; ask both, because a GP can answer one plausibly and still fail the other. A deal that fails all three is a financing story (GEN-07) regardless of how the headline IRR reads.


GP / sponsor-specific

Alignment, conduct, and the honesty of the track record. These apply to every deal type, debt or equity.

| ID | Question | Priority | Good-answer signals | Bad-answer signals | 03 ref | |---|---|---|---|---|---| | Q-GP-01 | "How much of your own capital is in this deal, on the same terms as LPs?" | Must-ask | A meaningful dollar amount on pari-passu terms; co-invest scales with deal size across the GP's deals. | "Our sweat equity is our investment"; co-invest is a fee waiver, not cash; token amount on better terms than LPs. | GEN-01 | | Q-GP-02 | "Can you restate your track record as net-to-LP IRR on fully-realized, exited deals only?" | Must-ask | Produces realized, net-to-LP figures; acknowledges losers; distinguishes realized from marked. | Offers only project-level or GP-level IRR; "most deals are still performing"; can't separate realized from unrealized. | GEN-05, GEN-14 | | Q-GP-03 | "Have you or your principals faced any regulatory action, enforcement, or investor litigation?" | Must-ask | A direct yes/no; if yes, full context and resolution offered unprompted. | Deflects to "nothing material"; blames the LP/regulator; a search surfaces something they didn't disclose. | GEN-02 | | Q-GP-04 | "How have your headcount and deal-monitoring capacity grown alongside AUM?" | Nice-to-ask | Team scaled with capital; named people own asset management; monitoring cadence described. | AUM multiplied while the team stayed flat; "we're lean and efficient" as the whole answer; no named asset manager. | GEN-04 |

Notes. Q-GP-02 is the single highest-yield question in the bank. A GP that cites only unrealized marks (GEN-14) and only project-level IRR (GEN-05) has given no validated LP-outcome data at all — that pairing is a RED cluster, not two soft answers. Escalate Q-GP-04 to must-ask whenever GEN-04 has fired.


Market-specific

Whether the deal's market assumptions are grounded or asserted. The second question fires only for assets 01-asset-class-norms.md marks variable.

| ID | Question | Priority | Good-answer signals | Bad-answer signals | 03 ref | |---|---|---|---|---|---| | Q-MKT-01 | "What submarket supply pipeline and absorption data support the rent-growth assumption?" | Must-ask | Cites submarket-level supply and absorption; rent growth tied to data, not the metro headline. | Metro-level optimism standing in for submarket data; "rents always go up here"; no supply pipeline acknowledged. | GEN-18 | | Q-MKT-02 (office / variable assets) | "How does the underwriting reflect post-2020 physical occupancy and sublease overhang in this submarket?" | Must-ask (if applicable) | Uses physical (not leased) occupancy; acknowledges the structural reset and sublease shadow supply. | Leans on a pre-2020 baseline; quotes leased occupancy only; treats WFH as fully reversed. | GEN-19 |

Notes. Q-MKT-02 applies to any asset class 01 marks variable (office, experiential retail, regulatory-exposed STR), not office alone. Pair Q-MKT-01 with GEN-13 (no downside case): a cycle-exposed market plus a single-point pro forma is sharper than either flag alone.


Fee / structure-specific

The fee stack, the waterfall, and the preferred return — what the LP pays and what protects the LP before the GP earns promote. Thresholds here come from 02-fee-stack-library.md.

| ID | Question | Priority | Good-answer signals | Bad-answer signals | 03 ref | |---|---|---|---|---|---| | Q-FEE-01 | "Can you provide the complete fee schedule and the full distribution waterfall?" | Must-ask | A full written schedule and waterfall; gross-to-net drag is computable from it. | "Standard market fees"; partial list; "the PPM has it" without producing it; fees surface only after commitment. | GEN-16 | | Q-FEE-02 | "Which service providers are GP-affiliated, what do they charge, and are those rates third-party-benchmarked?" | Must-ask | Names affiliated entities, discloses their fees, benchmarks them to market or discounts them. | "All arm's-length" without naming providers; affiliate fees undisclosed; no benchmark offered. | GEN-06 | | Q-FEE-03 | "Is the waterfall deal-by-deal or whole-of-fund, and is there a clawback?" | Must-ask | Whole-of-fund, or deal-by-deal with a secured/escrowed clawback; mechanism explained plainly. | Deal-by-deal with high promote and no clawback; can't explain the catch-up; "you get paid when we get paid." | EQUITY-01, EQUITY-02 | | Q-FEE-04 | "What preferred return do LPs receive before the GP earns promote, and is it cumulative and compounding?" | Must-ask | A pref at or above market for the asset class, cumulative, carrying forward and compounding unpaid amounts. | Pref below 6% or absent; non-cumulative; promote sits above a preferred-equity pref (turning it into common risk). | EQUITY-04, EQUITY-05, PREF-01 |

Notes. Q-FEE-02 catches what the fee inventory in 02 can miss: each affiliate fee can sit in-range while the aggregation through related parties is the problem. The test is disclosure and benchmarking, not the existence of an affiliate. Q-FEE-03's deal-by-deal structure is only RED when paired with a high promote and no clawback — ask all three parts.


Risk-specific

The debt, the financials, and — for debt funds — the loan book. Where the return story meets the things that can break it. The last three questions are debt-fund-conditional.

| ID | Question | Priority | Good-answer signals | Bad-answer signals | 03 ref | |---|---|---|---|---|---| | Q-RISK-01 | "When does the debt mature relative to the projected hold, and what's the refinance or extension plan?" | Must-ask | Debt matures at or after the planned exit; extension options or a refi-independent path exist. | Maturity falls inside the hold; "we'll refinance" with no terms; no plan if the refi market is shut. | GEN-09 | | Q-RISK-02 | "When does the rate cap expire relative to debt maturity, and what's the cost to extend it at current pricing?" | Must-ask | Cap covers the full hold or has a budgeted extension; current replacement cost is known. | Cap expires before maturity; extension cost not modeled; "rates should be lower by then." | GEN-10 | | Q-RISK-03 | "Can you provide trailing-twelve-month actuals, the rent roll, and complete debt terms?" | Must-ask | Full T-12, current rent roll, and all debt terms provided without friction. | T-3/T-6 only; rent roll withheld; "the financials are confidential until you commit." | GEN-12, GEN-15 | | Q-RISK-04 (HML / bridge fund) | "What is the average portfolio LTV on as-is value, not just ARV?" | Must-ask (if applicable) | Reports LTV on as-is value; a real equity cushion exists if the renovation thesis fails. | Quotes only LTV-on-ARV; can't produce as-is LTV; "our borrowers always complete." | HML-01 | | Q-RISK-05 (HML / credit fund) | "What is your historical default rate and realized recovery rate, including through 2020 and 2022–23?" | Must-ask (if applicable) | Discloses both default and recovery with workout timelines, across stress periods. | Default rate without recovery (or vice versa); "we've never had a loss"; silence on 2022–23. | HML-03, HML-04 | | Q-RISK-06 (credit fund) | "What is the fund's leverage ratio, and is the quoted LP IRR levered or unlevered?" | Must-ask (if applicable) | States fund-level leverage; clarifies the IRR is levered and shows the unlevered figure. | Won't disclose leverage; presents a levered IRR as if unlevered; "leverage is conservative" with no number. | CREDIT-01 |

Notes. Q-RISK-02 targets the specific 2022–24 failure mode behind many multifamily-syndication capital calls — the cap's expiry date, not the rate itself, is the trigger, so it's distinct from generic floating-rate exposure. Q-RISK-05's two halves travel together: a 2% default rate with 40% recovery is worse than 5% default with 90% recovery, so a GP disclosing only one number has told you nothing about realized loss.


Exit-specific

The terminal assumptions that drive the headline IRR — the exit cap and the refinance the plan may depend on.

| ID | Question | Priority | Good-answer signals | Bad-answer signals | 03 ref | |---|---|---|---|---|---| | Q-EXIT-01 | "Why is the exit cap below the going-in cap, and what's the IRR at an exit cap equal to or above going-in?" | Must-ask | Exit cap equals or exceeds going-in (no baked-in compression), or compression is justified by a specific, defensible thesis. | Exit cap below going-in with "cap rates will compress"; the IRR breaks at a flat exit cap; no sensitivity offered. | EQUITY-06 | | Q-EXIT-02 | "Does the business plan depend on a refinance, and what happens to distributions if the refi isn't available on the assumed terms?" | Must-ask | Capital return doesn't hinge on a refi; if it does, a credible fallback exists. | Distributions or capital return require a refi at lower rates; no fallback; "the refi market will reopen." | EQUITY-07 |

Notes. Q-EXIT-01 connects directly to Q-DS-01: an aggressive exit cap is the usual mechanism behind exit-dependent IRR. If both fire, the verdict should name the deal a financing story explicitly.


Distribution timing

When LP capital actually comes back — the J-curve question that two deals with identical headline IRRs can answer very differently. (Design-review addition, 2026-06-01.)

| ID | Question | Priority | Good-answer signals | Bad-answer signals | 03 ref | |---|---|---|---|---|---| | Q-DIST-01 | "What is the projected distribution schedule, and at what milestones does LP capital start returning?" | Must-ask | A specific schedule tied to operational triggers; clear on when distributions begin and what gates them. | "We'll distribute when the deal supports it" with no milestones; an IRR quoted with no distribution timing; silence. | GEN-11 | | Q-DIST-02 | "When are capital calls expected, and what's the consequence of a missed or late call?" | Nice-to-ask | A defined call schedule; the dilution/penalty mechanics are stated and reasonable. | "Calls as needed" with no notice period; punitive dilution buried in the docs; can't describe the mechanics. | — |

Notes. Q-DIST-01 is why two deals with the same IRR are not equivalent: a back-loaded deal concentrates all return risk at the exit (GEN-11). Q-DIST-02 has no 03 flag because it concerns the LP's own cash-management decision, not a deal defect — but a punitive missed-call provision is a real LP exposure.


LP liquidity / secondary market

The LP's own exit and tax mechanics — questions about the investor's position, not the asset. (Q-LIQ-01 is a design-review addition, 2026-06-01.)

| ID | Question | Priority | Good-answer signals | Bad-answer signals | 03 ref | |---|---|---|---|---|---| | Q-LIQ-01 | "What are my options if I need to exit before the hold period ends?" | Must-ask | Names a secondary platform or process, a realistic liquidity timeline, and is honest that there may be none. | "A secondary market may develop"; "we'll try to accommodate"; silence — i.e. illiquid with the lock-up undisclosed. | — | | Q-LIQ-02 | "When will K-1s be delivered each year, and have you historically delivered them before the filing deadline?" | Nice-to-ask | A committed delivery window with a track record of meeting it. | "As soon as we can"; a history of extensions forcing LPs to file late; no answer. | — |

Notes. This category has no 03 cross-references by design — these are LP-decision questions, not deal-defect flags. They belong here precisely because 03 is scoped to the deal's risks while the LP's own liquidity and tax timing are equally part of the commit-or-pass decision (see 01-asset-class-norms.md on lock-up by asset class). An honest "there is no liquidity" is a good answer; a vague promise of liquidity that doesn't exist is the bad one.


Provenance

The shared sources in 01-asset-class-norms.md → Provenance (ILPA due-diligence and alignment standards; Preqin / NCREIF realized-vs-marketed dispersion, why net-to-LP realized figures (Q-GP-02) are the only validated track record), plus:

  • SEC enforcement patterns. The fact patterns that make Q-GP-02 and Q-GP-03 high-yield — undisclosed affiliate fees, unrealized marks as returns, misleading track-record IRRs.
  • Post-2022 distress case studies. The rate-cap-expiry / frozen-refi failures of 2022–24 — the source for Q-RISK-01, Q-RISK-02, and Q-EXIT-02 as a connected line of questioning.

Last reviewed: 2026-06-03. Questions and bad-answer signals derive from the flags in 03-red-flag-library.md; when a flag's ID or threshold changes, update the matching question's cross-reference here. New questions append to the relevant category and take the next ID in their Q-<CAT>-NN sequence so SKILL.md references stay stable.