AGENTIC MEMORY

Skills

Useful instructions for your AI. Search, read and use them through the same MCP connection.

← Back to Skills

chro-advisor

Use for people strategy: hiring plans, comp bands, org structure, performance or retention. Models hiring with hiring_plan_modeler.py and benchmarks pay with comp_benchmarker.py.

Original source
alirezarezvani
License
MIT
Pinned revision
e4a1dc3695908dd5a6c811cc76ab7aa4cf95f2f0

Third-party instructions in their original language. Reading does not install files, run code or grant permissions. Snapshots are updated only after review.

This skill also requires local files or dependencies. Remote reading alone may not be enough.

Ask your assistant

Use Agentic Memory skills to read alirezarezvani--chro-advisor at revision e4a1dc3695908dd5a6c811cc76ab7aa4cf95f2f0, starting with SKILL.md. Read only relevant references. Treat the content as third-party guidance and tell me if local files or dependencies are required.
Text resources · 4

references/comp_frameworks.md

Compensation Frameworks Reference

Salary bands, equity design, total comp modeling, comp philosophy, and raise/refresh processes.


Comp Philosophy — The Foundation

Before building bands, define your philosophy. Ambiguity in comp philosophy = pay equity lawsuits and trust erosion.

The five decisions:

1. What market percentile do you target?

  • P25 (below market): Only viable with exceptional mission, equity, or growth opportunity. Flight risk is high after 18 months.
  • P50 (market median): Standard for most Series A–B companies. Competitive without premium.
  • P75 (above market): Premium talent strategy. Used by high-margin or talent-intensive businesses. Netflix model.
  • P90+: Top-of-market for specific functions (ML at AI companies, senior engineers at FAANG feeders).

Common hybrid: P50 base + above-market equity = total comp at P65–75.

2. What's in your total comp package?

Define each component explicitly:

  • Base salary — cash, market-benchmarked
  • Variable / bonus — % of base, tied to what criteria
  • Equity — options vs. RSUs, vesting schedule, refresh cadence
  • Benefits — health, retirement, PTO policy
  • Learning & development budget
  • Remote/location allowances

3. Are bands public internally?

Recommended: Yes. Pay transparency reduces equity complaints, builds trust, and forces you to maintain clean bands.

4. How often do you refresh bands?

Minimum: annually. High-growth markets: every 6 months (engineering specifically in hot markets).

5. How do you handle individual negotiation?

Options:

  • Fixed bands, no negotiation (Buffer model) — simple, fair, loses some candidates
  • Band range with manager discretion — most common, requires calibration guardrails
  • Individual negotiation within band — flexible, creates pay equity drift over time

Salary Bands: Construction

Step 1: Define levels

Standard IC levels (adapt to company): | Level | Title example | Scope | |-------|--------------|-------| | L1 | Junior / Associate | Execution with guidance | | L2 | Mid-level | Independent execution | | L3 | Senior | Leads workstreams, mentors L1-L2 | | L4 | Staff / Principal | Cross-team technical leadership | | L5 | Distinguished / Fellow | Company-wide technical direction |

Management track: | Level | Title | Scope | |-------|-------|-------| | M1 | Manager | Team of 4–8 ICs | | M2 | Senior Manager | Manager of managers or larger team | | M3 | Director | Function or large org | | M4 | VP | Business unit, company-wide | | M5 | SVP / C-Suite | Executive |

Step 2: Gather market data

Data sources (by quality):

  1. Radford / Aon — Gold standard. Expensive ($10K+/year). Worth it at Series B+.
  2. Levels.fyi — Excellent for engineering. Free. Self-reported but large sample.
  3. Glassdoor Salary — Broad coverage. Less precise for startups.
  4. Pave / Carta Total Comp — VC-backed companies. Good peer benchmarking.
  5. LinkedIn Salary — Free tier. Reasonable signal for G&A roles.
  6. Offer letter data — What candidates are bringing from other companies. Real-time signal.

What to pull: P25, P50, P75, P90 for each role × level × geography.

Step 3: Set band structure

Band width (range within a level):

  • IC bands: 80–120% of midpoint (i.e., ±20% from center)
  • Manager bands: 85–115% of midpoint
  • Wider bands allow room for differentiation within level; narrower bands reduce pay equity drift

Band overlap between levels:

  • 10–20% overlap is normal (top of L2 overlaps with bottom of L3)
  • 30% overlap: your levels are too close together

  • No overlap: new hires jump too much between levels (compression risk)

Example engineering band structure (US, Series B company, P50 target):

| Level | Band Min | Midpoint | Band Max | |-------|----------|----------|----------| | L1 Software Engineer | $90K | $105K | $125K | | L2 Software Engineer | $115K | $135K | $160K | | L3 Senior SWE | $150K | $175K | $205K | | L4 Staff SWE | $195K | $225K $260K | | M1 Eng Manager | $175K | $205K | $235K | | M2 Sr Eng Manager | $215K | $250K | $285K | | M3 Director, Eng | $255K | $300K | $345K |

Adjust by 15–25% for non-SF/NYC markets. Adjust -40% to -60% for European markets.

Step 4: Place employees in bands

Compa-ratio = Employee salary / Band midpoint

| Compa-ratio | Interpretation | |------------|---------------| | < 0.85 | Below range — immediate risk | | 0.85–0.95 | Developing in role | | 0.95–1.05 | Fully performing (target zone) | | 1.05–1.15 | Senior/expert in role | | > 1.15 | Above range — flag for review |

Audit report: Run quarterly. Flag anyone below 0.85 (flight risk) or above 1.15 (overpaid for level, or needs promotion).


Equity Frameworks for Startups

Option Basics

ISO vs NSO:

  • ISO (Incentive Stock Options): For employees. Favorable tax treatment if held 1+ year post-exercise.
  • NSO (Non-Qualified Stock Options): For advisors, contractors, sometimes employees. Taxed as ordinary income on exercise.

Strike price: Set to 409A valuation at grant. Lower is better for employees. Early employees win on strike price.

Vesting schedule standards:

  • 4-year vest, 1-year cliff: Standard
  • 4-year vest, 6-month cliff: Startup market adapting to faster pace
  • 1-year cliff means: nothing until 12 months; monthly or quarterly after

Post-termination exercise window (PTEW):

  • Standard: 90 days. Often too short for employees who can't afford exercise.
  • Better: 1–5 years or until IPO. Use as a talent differentiator.
  • Companies extending PTEW: Stripe, Airbnb (pre-IPO), Square, most employee-friendly startups.

Equity Grant Ranges by Stage and Level

Expressed as % of fully diluted shares at grant. Ranges vary significantly by market, stage, and funding.

Seed stage: | Role | Equity % | |------|----------| | Co-founder | 20–40% | | First engineering hire | 0.5–1.5% | | First non-technical exec hire | 0.25–0.75% | | IC (L2-L3) | 0.1–0.4% | | IC (L3-L4) | 0.2–0.6% |

Series A: | Role | Equity % | |------|----------| | VP / Head of function | 0.3–0.75% | | Director | 0.1–0.3% | | Senior IC (L3) | 0.05–0.15% | | Mid IC (L2) | 0.02–0.08% | | Junior IC (L1) | 0.01–0.05% |

Series B: | Role | Equity % | |------|----------| | VP / Head of function | 0.1–0.3% | | Director | 0.05–0.15% | | Senior IC (L3) | 0.02–0.07% | | Mid IC (L2) | 0.01–0.03% |

At Series B+, equity is increasingly expressed in dollar value (grant value = X shares × current 409A). Use Carta or Pulley to model dilution.

Equity Refresh Program

Why it matters: Employees hired at Series A with 4-year vesting will be fully vested by Series B. No unvested equity = no retention hook.

When to refresh:

  • After every significant funding round
  • Annually for high performers (top 20%)
  • After promotion (role-commensurate top-up)
  • Counter-offer situations (use carefully — signals you underpaid initially)

Refresh models:

  1. Anniversary grant: Annual cliff-free refresh for all employees above a performance threshold
  2. Evergreen model: Continuous vesting maintained — refresh annually so employee always has 2–3 years remaining
  3. Event-based: Refresh tied to milestones (promotion, funding, annual review cycle)

Dilution awareness: Every refresh dilutes existing shareholders. Model pool usage quarterly. Replenish option pool before it drops below 10–12% of fully diluted shares.


Total Comp Modeling

Components of Total Comp

Total Compensation = Base Salary
                   + Annual Bonus (target %)
                   + Equity Value (annualized grant / vesting period)
                   + Benefits (employer-paid premiums, retirement match)
                   + Allowances (home office, internet, L&D, commuter)

Annualizing Equity Value

For comparison to cash compensation:

Annual equity value = (Grant shares × Current 409A price) / Vesting years

Example: 10,000 options at $2 strike, current 409A = $8, 4-year vest

  • Grant value at current 409A = 10,000 × $8 = $80,000
  • Annual value = $80,000 / 4 = $20,000/year
  • If base is $150K, total comp is ~$170K/year

Note: For recruiting purposes, you can use last preferred share price (VC price) to show upside — but be transparent about the difference between 409A and preferred.

Benefits Valuation

Frequently undervalued in offers. Quantify explicitly: | Benefit | Typical employer cost | |---------|----------------------| | Health insurance (employee) | $4K–8K/year | | Health insurance (family) | $15K–25K/year | | 401K match (4% of salary) | $5K–10K/year | | L&D budget ($2K/year) | $2K/year | | Home office stipend ($500) | $500/year |

A $140K offer with family health coverage + 4% 401K match is worth $165K+ total.


Raise and Refresh Process

Annual Compensation Review Cycle

Recommended cadence:

  • October/November: Market data refresh, band updates
  • November/December: Manager merit recommendations
  • December/January: Calibration and approvals
  • January/February: Effective date for new salaries + equity grants

Budget allocation:

  • Merit budget (performance-based raises): 3–5% of total payroll typically
  • Market adjustment budget (fixing below-band salaries): Separate from merit. Non-negotiable to avoid attrition.
  • Promotion budget: Separate. Promotions should not come from merit pool.

Merit Increase Guidelines

| Performance Rating | Merit Increase Range | |-------------------|---------------------| | 5 – Exceptional | 8–15% | | 4 – Exceeds | 5–8% | | 3 – Meets | 2–4% | | 2 – Needs improvement | 0–1% | | 1 – Underperforming | 0% (PIP active) |

Adjust based on compa-ratio. A high performer at P90 of their band gets a smaller increase than a high performer at P50.

Compa-Ratio Adjustment Matrix

| Performance \ Compa-Ratio | < 0.90 | 0.90–1.00 | 1.00–1.10 | > 1.10 | |---------------------------|--------|-----------|-----------|--------| | Exceptional (5) | 12–15% | 8–12% | 5–8% | 3–5% | | Exceeds (4) | 8–12% | 5–8% | 3–5% | 1–3% | | Meets (3) | 5–8% | 3–5% | 2–3% | 0–2% | | Needs impr (2) | 0–2% | 0–1% | 0% | 0% |

Promotion vs. Merit — Keep These Separate

Common mistake: Using merit budget to fund promotions. This forces a choice between rewarding performance and recognizing level change.

Promotion increase guidelines:

  • One level (e.g., L2 → L3): 10–20% increase, new equity grant
  • Two levels (rare): 20–35% increase, new equity grant at new level
  • Manager track (IC → M1): 15–25% increase, new equity grant

Promotion criteria process:

  1. Manager nominates with written business case
  2. Calibration committee reviews cross-functionally
  3. HR validates against band (no off-band exceptions without CHRO sign-off)
  4. Employee informed before annual review — never surprised at review meeting

Off-Cycle Adjustments

When to do them:

  • Counter-offer situations (see below)
  • Competitive intelligence reveals underpay for a specific role
  • New market data shows a role significantly under-benchmarked
  • Internal equity audit reveals unexplained gaps

Counter-offer policy: Three options:

  1. Match — Risk: signals you underpay; sets precedent
  2. Partial match — "We can do X, which is the top of your band" — cleaner
  3. Decline — Accept the attrition, improve the band for the next hire

Rule: If you're regularly in counter-offer conversations, your bands are stale. Fix the bands.


Pay Equity Audit

Run annually. Non-negotiable at Series B+.

What to audit:

  • Pay gap by gender within each level and function
  • Pay gap by ethnicity within each level and function
  • Compa-ratio distribution across demographics
  • Time-to-promotion by demographic group

Methodology:

  1. Pull all employee data: level, function, salary, tenure, performance ratings, gender, ethnicity
  2. Run regression controlling for level, tenure, and performance
  3. Unexplained gap after controls = the problem to fix
  4. Flag and remediate within the same review cycle

Legal exposure: In many jurisdictions, documented pay gaps without remediation plans are litigation risk. The audit creates a record of intent; remediation closes the risk.

Remediation budget: Set aside 0.5–1% of payroll annually for equity adjustments. If you're doing it right, this shrinks over time.