references/comp_frameworks.md
Compensation Frameworks Reference
Salary bands, equity design, total comp modeling, comp philosophy, and raise/refresh processes.
Comp Philosophy — The Foundation
Before building bands, define your philosophy. Ambiguity in comp philosophy = pay equity lawsuits and trust erosion.
The five decisions:
1. What market percentile do you target?
- P25 (below market): Only viable with exceptional mission, equity, or growth opportunity. Flight risk is high after 18 months.
- P50 (market median): Standard for most Series A–B companies. Competitive without premium.
- P75 (above market): Premium talent strategy. Used by high-margin or talent-intensive businesses. Netflix model.
- P90+: Top-of-market for specific functions (ML at AI companies, senior engineers at FAANG feeders).
Common hybrid: P50 base + above-market equity = total comp at P65–75.
2. What's in your total comp package?
Define each component explicitly:
- Base salary — cash, market-benchmarked
- Variable / bonus — % of base, tied to what criteria
- Equity — options vs. RSUs, vesting schedule, refresh cadence
- Benefits — health, retirement, PTO policy
- Learning & development budget
- Remote/location allowances
3. Are bands public internally?
Recommended: Yes. Pay transparency reduces equity complaints, builds trust, and forces you to maintain clean bands.
4. How often do you refresh bands?
Minimum: annually. High-growth markets: every 6 months (engineering specifically in hot markets).
5. How do you handle individual negotiation?
Options:
- Fixed bands, no negotiation (Buffer model) — simple, fair, loses some candidates
- Band range with manager discretion — most common, requires calibration guardrails
- Individual negotiation within band — flexible, creates pay equity drift over time
Salary Bands: Construction
Step 1: Define levels
Standard IC levels (adapt to company): | Level | Title example | Scope | |-------|--------------|-------| | L1 | Junior / Associate | Execution with guidance | | L2 | Mid-level | Independent execution | | L3 | Senior | Leads workstreams, mentors L1-L2 | | L4 | Staff / Principal | Cross-team technical leadership | | L5 | Distinguished / Fellow | Company-wide technical direction |
Management track: | Level | Title | Scope | |-------|-------|-------| | M1 | Manager | Team of 4–8 ICs | | M2 | Senior Manager | Manager of managers or larger team | | M3 | Director | Function or large org | | M4 | VP | Business unit, company-wide | | M5 | SVP / C-Suite | Executive |
Step 2: Gather market data
Data sources (by quality):
- Radford / Aon — Gold standard. Expensive ($10K+/year). Worth it at Series B+.
- Levels.fyi — Excellent for engineering. Free. Self-reported but large sample.
- Glassdoor Salary — Broad coverage. Less precise for startups.
- Pave / Carta Total Comp — VC-backed companies. Good peer benchmarking.
- LinkedIn Salary — Free tier. Reasonable signal for G&A roles.
- Offer letter data — What candidates are bringing from other companies. Real-time signal.
What to pull: P25, P50, P75, P90 for each role × level × geography.
Step 3: Set band structure
Band width (range within a level):
- IC bands: 80–120% of midpoint (i.e., ±20% from center)
- Manager bands: 85–115% of midpoint
- Wider bands allow room for differentiation within level; narrower bands reduce pay equity drift
Band overlap between levels:
- 10–20% overlap is normal (top of L2 overlaps with bottom of L3)
-
30% overlap: your levels are too close together
- No overlap: new hires jump too much between levels (compression risk)
Example engineering band structure (US, Series B company, P50 target):
| Level | Band Min | Midpoint | Band Max | |-------|----------|----------|----------| | L1 Software Engineer | $90K | $105K | $125K | | L2 Software Engineer | $115K | $135K | $160K | | L3 Senior SWE | $150K | $175K | $205K | | L4 Staff SWE | $195K | $225K $260K | | M1 Eng Manager | $175K | $205K | $235K | | M2 Sr Eng Manager | $215K | $250K | $285K | | M3 Director, Eng | $255K | $300K | $345K |
Adjust by 15–25% for non-SF/NYC markets. Adjust -40% to -60% for European markets.
Step 4: Place employees in bands
Compa-ratio = Employee salary / Band midpoint
| Compa-ratio | Interpretation | |------------|---------------| | < 0.85 | Below range — immediate risk | | 0.85–0.95 | Developing in role | | 0.95–1.05 | Fully performing (target zone) | | 1.05–1.15 | Senior/expert in role | | > 1.15 | Above range — flag for review |
Audit report: Run quarterly. Flag anyone below 0.85 (flight risk) or above 1.15 (overpaid for level, or needs promotion).
Equity Frameworks for Startups
Option Basics
ISO vs NSO:
- ISO (Incentive Stock Options): For employees. Favorable tax treatment if held 1+ year post-exercise.
- NSO (Non-Qualified Stock Options): For advisors, contractors, sometimes employees. Taxed as ordinary income on exercise.
Strike price: Set to 409A valuation at grant. Lower is better for employees. Early employees win on strike price.
Vesting schedule standards:
- 4-year vest, 1-year cliff: Standard
- 4-year vest, 6-month cliff: Startup market adapting to faster pace
- 1-year cliff means: nothing until 12 months; monthly or quarterly after
Post-termination exercise window (PTEW):
- Standard: 90 days. Often too short for employees who can't afford exercise.
- Better: 1–5 years or until IPO. Use as a talent differentiator.
- Companies extending PTEW: Stripe, Airbnb (pre-IPO), Square, most employee-friendly startups.
Equity Grant Ranges by Stage and Level
Expressed as % of fully diluted shares at grant. Ranges vary significantly by market, stage, and funding.
Seed stage: | Role | Equity % | |------|----------| | Co-founder | 20–40% | | First engineering hire | 0.5–1.5% | | First non-technical exec hire | 0.25–0.75% | | IC (L2-L3) | 0.1–0.4% | | IC (L3-L4) | 0.2–0.6% |
Series A: | Role | Equity % | |------|----------| | VP / Head of function | 0.3–0.75% | | Director | 0.1–0.3% | | Senior IC (L3) | 0.05–0.15% | | Mid IC (L2) | 0.02–0.08% | | Junior IC (L1) | 0.01–0.05% |
Series B: | Role | Equity % | |------|----------| | VP / Head of function | 0.1–0.3% | | Director | 0.05–0.15% | | Senior IC (L3) | 0.02–0.07% | | Mid IC (L2) | 0.01–0.03% |
At Series B+, equity is increasingly expressed in dollar value (grant value = X shares × current 409A). Use Carta or Pulley to model dilution.
Equity Refresh Program
Why it matters: Employees hired at Series A with 4-year vesting will be fully vested by Series B. No unvested equity = no retention hook.
When to refresh:
- After every significant funding round
- Annually for high performers (top 20%)
- After promotion (role-commensurate top-up)
- Counter-offer situations (use carefully — signals you underpaid initially)
Refresh models:
- Anniversary grant: Annual cliff-free refresh for all employees above a performance threshold
- Evergreen model: Continuous vesting maintained — refresh annually so employee always has 2–3 years remaining
- Event-based: Refresh tied to milestones (promotion, funding, annual review cycle)
Dilution awareness: Every refresh dilutes existing shareholders. Model pool usage quarterly. Replenish option pool before it drops below 10–12% of fully diluted shares.
Total Comp Modeling
Components of Total Comp
Total Compensation = Base Salary
+ Annual Bonus (target %)
+ Equity Value (annualized grant / vesting period)
+ Benefits (employer-paid premiums, retirement match)
+ Allowances (home office, internet, L&D, commuter)
Annualizing Equity Value
For comparison to cash compensation:
Annual equity value = (Grant shares × Current 409A price) / Vesting years
Example: 10,000 options at $2 strike, current 409A = $8, 4-year vest
- Grant value at current 409A = 10,000 × $8 = $80,000
- Annual value = $80,000 / 4 = $20,000/year
- If base is $150K, total comp is ~$170K/year
Note: For recruiting purposes, you can use last preferred share price (VC price) to show upside — but be transparent about the difference between 409A and preferred.
Benefits Valuation
Frequently undervalued in offers. Quantify explicitly: | Benefit | Typical employer cost | |---------|----------------------| | Health insurance (employee) | $4K–8K/year | | Health insurance (family) | $15K–25K/year | | 401K match (4% of salary) | $5K–10K/year | | L&D budget ($2K/year) | $2K/year | | Home office stipend ($500) | $500/year |
A $140K offer with family health coverage + 4% 401K match is worth $165K+ total.
Raise and Refresh Process
Annual Compensation Review Cycle
Recommended cadence:
- October/November: Market data refresh, band updates
- November/December: Manager merit recommendations
- December/January: Calibration and approvals
- January/February: Effective date for new salaries + equity grants
Budget allocation:
- Merit budget (performance-based raises): 3–5% of total payroll typically
- Market adjustment budget (fixing below-band salaries): Separate from merit. Non-negotiable to avoid attrition.
- Promotion budget: Separate. Promotions should not come from merit pool.
Merit Increase Guidelines
| Performance Rating | Merit Increase Range | |-------------------|---------------------| | 5 – Exceptional | 8–15% | | 4 – Exceeds | 5–8% | | 3 – Meets | 2–4% | | 2 – Needs improvement | 0–1% | | 1 – Underperforming | 0% (PIP active) |
Adjust based on compa-ratio. A high performer at P90 of their band gets a smaller increase than a high performer at P50.
Compa-Ratio Adjustment Matrix
| Performance \ Compa-Ratio | < 0.90 | 0.90–1.00 | 1.00–1.10 | > 1.10 | |---------------------------|--------|-----------|-----------|--------| | Exceptional (5) | 12–15% | 8–12% | 5–8% | 3–5% | | Exceeds (4) | 8–12% | 5–8% | 3–5% | 1–3% | | Meets (3) | 5–8% | 3–5% | 2–3% | 0–2% | | Needs impr (2) | 0–2% | 0–1% | 0% | 0% |
Promotion vs. Merit — Keep These Separate
Common mistake: Using merit budget to fund promotions. This forces a choice between rewarding performance and recognizing level change.
Promotion increase guidelines:
- One level (e.g., L2 → L3): 10–20% increase, new equity grant
- Two levels (rare): 20–35% increase, new equity grant at new level
- Manager track (IC → M1): 15–25% increase, new equity grant
Promotion criteria process:
- Manager nominates with written business case
- Calibration committee reviews cross-functionally
- HR validates against band (no off-band exceptions without CHRO sign-off)
- Employee informed before annual review — never surprised at review meeting
Off-Cycle Adjustments
When to do them:
- Counter-offer situations (see below)
- Competitive intelligence reveals underpay for a specific role
- New market data shows a role significantly under-benchmarked
- Internal equity audit reveals unexplained gaps
Counter-offer policy: Three options:
- Match — Risk: signals you underpay; sets precedent
- Partial match — "We can do X, which is the top of your band" — cleaner
- Decline — Accept the attrition, improve the band for the next hire
Rule: If you're regularly in counter-offer conversations, your bands are stale. Fix the bands.
Pay Equity Audit
Run annually. Non-negotiable at Series B+.
What to audit:
- Pay gap by gender within each level and function
- Pay gap by ethnicity within each level and function
- Compa-ratio distribution across demographics
- Time-to-promotion by demographic group
Methodology:
- Pull all employee data: level, function, salary, tenure, performance ratings, gender, ethnicity
- Run regression controlling for level, tenure, and performance
- Unexplained gap after controls = the problem to fix
- Flag and remediate within the same review cycle
Legal exposure: In many jurisdictions, documented pay gaps without remediation plans are litigation risk. The audit creates a record of intent; remediation closes the risk.
Remediation budget: Set aside 0.5–1% of payroll annually for equity adjustments. If you're doing it right, this shrinks over time.