references/contracts_playbook.md
Contracts Playbook — Standard Startup Agreements
Reference for the 7 contracts every startup signs in its first 5 years and the clause traps to avoid in each. Not legal advice. Bring redlines to qualified counsel.
1. Master Service Agreement (MSA) — Vendor Side (you signing theirs)
What it is: The umbrella contract for an ongoing relationship with a vendor (cloud, tooling, services, agencies). Usually paired with one or more SOWs / Order Forms.
Top 5 redlines to push:
- Auto-renewal: Cut notice period to 30 days max. Reject 60/90/180 day notice.
- Liability cap: Insist on 12 months of fees. Reject "fees in the preceding 3 months" (too narrow).
- Mutual indemnification: Reject one-sided. Mirror the scope on both sides.
- IP ownership of deliverables: All work product belongs to you. Vendor retains rights to pre-existing tools / methodologies, granted back to you for use.
- Data: DPA + return-or-destroy on termination. Specifically: vendor cannot use your data to train AI models.
Bonus catch: Watch for "Vendor may modify these terms upon notice" — this means the contract you signed isn't the contract you have.
2. Customer SaaS Agreement (your paper)
Standard structure:
- License grant (subscription, scope, term)
- Acceptable use policy (what customer can/can't do)
- Fees & payment (annual prepay vs. monthly, late fee, currency)
- Service Level Agreement (uptime %, credits, exclusions)
- Confidentiality (mutual, residuals carve-out)
- Data Protection (DPA exhibit, subprocessor list, security commitments)
- Warranties (limited, disclaim implied)
- Indemnification (mutual, IP-infringement focused)
- Limitation of liability (12 months fees, carve-outs for IP/data breach/willful)
- Term & termination (term, termination for cause, termination for convenience)
Founder traps when accepting customer redlines:
- "Most-favored-nation" pricing (means you can never give anyone else a better deal).
- Uncapped liability for data breach with no minimum threshold.
- Customer right to perpetual license-back of "improvements" to your product.
- Customer "ownership" of any custom configuration (often hiding IP creep).
- Source-code escrow with auto-release triggers tied to customer convenience.
3. Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA)
One-way (you receiving): Acceptable to sign without redlines for short evaluations.
Mutual NDA (both directions): The default for ongoing discussions.
Critical carve-outs (always include):
- Residuals: Information retained in unaided memory after end of engagement is not confidential.
- Independent development: If you build something similar without using their info, it's yours.
- Public domain: Information already public is not confidential.
- Rightfully received: Information received from a third party without confidentiality obligation.
- Required by law: Information disclosed under subpoena (with notice).
Founder trap: NDAs that prevent you from "engaging in similar business" — that's a non-compete in disguise. Strip it out.
4. Data Processing Agreement (DPA)
Required when: Personal data of EU residents flows (GDPR Article 28), or California residents (CCPA / CPRA), or HIPAA-covered data, or biometrics in IL/TX/WA (BIPA).
Standard structure (GDPR-aligned):
- Scope of processing (what data, what purpose)
- Controller / Processor designation
- Subprocessor list + flow-down obligations
- Data subject rights (access, deletion, portability)
- Security measures (encryption, access controls, training)
- Breach notification timelines (within 72 hours for GDPR)
- Audit rights (annual, reasonable)
- International transfer mechanism (SCCs, adequacy decision, BCRs)
- Return-or-destroy on termination
Templates: Use IAPP, EU Commission SCCs, or vendor-friendly DPA (e.g., Vanta's, Stripe's).
Founder trap: Missing DPA when EU/CA data flows = contract may be unenforceable AND regulatory fine exposure.
5. Employment Agreement / Offer Letter
Must-have provisions:
- At-will employment (US most states; not enforceable in MT for example)
- Compensation: salary, bonus structure, equity (option grant separately documented)
- Invention assignment: all IP created during employment using company resources belongs to company
- Confidentiality: ongoing duty, surviving termination
- Non-solicit: 12 months post-termination, employees + customers (carve out general advertising)
- Non-compete: state-dependent (CA, ND, OK, DC: void; many other states: enforceable if reasonable)
- Arbitration: mutual, AAA or JAMS rules, employer pays fees
Founder traps:
- Forgetting to require employees to sign before starting work (otherwise IP assignment is weak).
- Not including a "previously created inventions" exhibit (lets founders document pre-existing IP brought into the company).
- Skipping background checks for senior hires.
6. Contractor / 1099 Agreement
Critical differences from employment:
- IP assignment is NOT automatic. Without a written clause, the contractor owns what they create (under US law, "work for hire" applies only to specific categories of work).
- Misclassification risk: If a contractor functions like an employee (controlled hours, exclusive engagement, supplied equipment), tax authorities can reclassify, triggering back taxes + penalties.
- No benefits, no withholding, contractor handles their own taxes.
Must-have provisions:
- Explicit work-for-hire OR written IP assignment ("Contractor hereby assigns all right, title, and interest...").
- Independent contractor status: contractor controls means and methods.
- Termination: 30-day notice, immediate for cause.
- Indemnification: contractor indemnifies you for misclassification claims if they misrepresent status.
Tooling: Use Deel, Remote, or Velocity Global for international contractors to handle classification correctly.
7. Equity Agreements (Option Grants, Advisor Grants)
Employee option grant:
- Strike price: must be ≥ fair market value (FMV) at grant date (409A valuation, refreshed annually).
- Vesting: standard 4 years, 1 year cliff, monthly thereafter.
- Exercise window post-termination: 90 days standard; 7-10 years is founder-friendly.
- ISO vs NSO: ISOs have tax advantages (long-term capital gains if held) but limits ($100K vest/year) and US-citizen-only.
Advisor grant (FAST template by Founder Institute):
- 0.1% - 1% equity vested over 1-2 years, depending on level and stage.
- 2-year vesting, no cliff (advisors are tested through engagement, not retention).
- Single trigger acceleration on change of control (rare; double trigger more common).
Founder trap:
- Issuing options before completing the 409A valuation — strike price might be challenged by IRS.
- Verbal promises about acceleration — must be in writing.
- Forgetting to issue option grants to early employees within 90 days of hire (loses ISO eligibility).
Quick Triage Heuristics
When you have 5 minutes to look at a contract:
- Find the liability cap. No cap or > 24 months of fees = red flag.
- Find the indemnity clauses. One-sided = red flag.
- Find the IP clause. Vague or "as agreed" = red flag.
- Find the term + termination. Auto-renewal with > 30 day notice = red flag.
- Find the choice of law/venue. Exclusive in counterparty home jurisdiction = red flag.
Run scripts/contract_risk_scanner.py for the automated version.
Final reminder: This is a triage playbook. Every contract over $100K or longer than 1 year deserves outside counsel review. Every contract that touches personal data deserves a privacy attorney. Every term sheet deserves a securities / venture attorney. Period.