references/deal_desk_canon.md
Deal Desk Canon
Operating practice for per-deal review and approval routing in B2B SaaS / enterprise software. Compiled from authoritative deal-desk and revenue-operations sources.
Why a deal desk exists
The deal desk is the operational gate between sales and finance/legal. Its job:
- Standardize discount approval so the same discount-percent always routes the same way.
- Defend gross margin by quantifying the actual margin loss from a proposed discount (not just the discount percent).
- Triage commercial terms so legal review hits only the deals that need it.
- Speed up the deals that should be fast by routing simple deals to AE/Manager authority and reserving CFO/CRO attention for the consequential ones.
Without a deal desk, every above-band deal becomes a 1:1 negotiation between an AE and a finance leader, which is slow, inconsistent, and creates pricing-integrity drift over time.
Operating tenets
These are the non-negotiables — adopted across every reference cited below.
- Never auto-approve. Even green deals get a named approver. The skill outputs who must sign, not the deal is fine.
- Margin, not discount. A 30% discount on an 80%-gross-margin product destroys 37.5% of the margin dollars (COGS is fixed, so every discounted dollar comes straight out of margin) — not 30%. See
discount_economics.mdfor the math. - The chain stops at the lowest hop that has authority. Over-routing trains reps to over-discount because they expect VP attention anyway.
- Critical signals override composite. A high-composite deal with uncapped indemnity is still a DECLINE.
- Modifiers must be explicit. Enterprise floor (large ARR forces VP review) and SMB fast-lane (small deals can skip a hop) are surfaced; hidden adjustments destroy audit trails.
- The deal desk is a router, not a salesperson. It does not negotiate; it routes the negotiation to the named human.
- One source of truth per deal. The intake template is the spec. Re-pricings or term changes create a new intake, not an edit-in-place.
Standard approval bands (industry-customary)
Default policy (override with policy_thresholds in input JSON):
| Discount band | Approver | Typical cycle | |---|---|---| | 0% - 15% | AE | same-day | | 15% - 25% | Sales Manager | 1 business day | | 25% - 35% | Director of Sales | 2 business days | | 35% - 50% | VP Sales | 3 business days | | 50%+ | CFO + CRO | 5+ business days |
Enterprise-software profile shifts bands upward (larger ACVs absorb deeper discounts). Services profile shifts downward (margin-thin). Marketplace profile is tightly capped (take-rate is the lever).
Tier and ARR modifiers
- Enterprise floor: Deals at ARR >= profile threshold force VP-level review even on small discounts. Rationale: the customer is consequential regardless of the discount.
- SMB fast-lane: Deals at ARR <= profile threshold can drop one hop (only if discount is within the second band). Rationale: cycle time matters more than marginal margin defense on a $12K deal.
Sources
- SaaStr — Jason Lemkin's deal-desk playbooks emphasize that the deal desk's primary job is defending gross margin and pricing integrity, not just routing discounts. https://www.saastr.com/
- Winning by Design — Jacco van der Kooij + Jason Reichl, Bowtie Funnel and Revenue Architecture. Establishes that the deal desk owns the gate between Acquisition (sales) and Retention (CS) — bad-term deals cost more in churn than they earn in ARR. https://winningbydesign.com/
- Forrester Research — Deal desk maturity model (4 stages: ad-hoc → formal → strategic → predictive). Most companies hit a wall at stage 2 because they lack the data infrastructure to score deals consistently.
- RevOps Co-op — Community playbooks (operating notes from Iceberg RevOps, Sapphire Ventures, others). Emphasizes that the deal desk is a routing function, not an approval function. The named approver is always a human.
- OpenView Venture Partners — State of the SaaS Sales Org annual benchmarks. Documents discount-band conventions across stage (seed → growth → late-stage) and shows that median discount creeps up year-over-year unless deal-desk discipline is enforced. https://openviewpartners.com/
- Bridge Group SaaS AE Compensation Research — Annual survey of B2B SaaS AE comp + quota. Establishes that AE discount authority above 15-20% destroys quota attainment math (because the AE under-prices to close).
- Salesforce Deal Desk Best Practices — Internal Salesforce documentation (Trailhead + RevOps blog). Codifies the queue model: every above-AE-authority deal enters a queue with SLA. Aging deals escalate automatically.
Patterns to surface in any deal-desk review packet
- Composite score with per-dimension breakdown.
- Named approver chain with the hop where the discount lands highlighted.
- Estimated cycle days based on hop count.
- Any CRITICAL signals (uncapped indemnity, MFN, perpetual license-back, missing DPA).
- The standard counter-language for any HIGH/CRITICAL redline.
- A single explicit statement: "This is a routing recommendation. The named approvers must sign."