AGENTIC MEMORY

Skills

Useful instructions for your AI. Search, read and use them through the same MCP connection.

← Back to Skills

commercial-policy

Use when writing or revising discount rules: discount matrix, approver thresholds, exception flows and the deal framework sales works under. Builds the matrix with discount_matrix_builder.py, routes exceptions with exception_router.py and checks the policy with policy_linter.py.

Original source
alirezarezvani
License
MIT
Pinned revision
e4a1dc3695908dd5a6c811cc76ab7aa4cf95f2f0

Third-party instructions in their original language. Reading does not install files, run code or grant permissions. Snapshots are updated only after review.

This skill also requires local files or dependencies. Remote reading alone may not be enough.

Ask your assistant

Use Agentic Memory skills to read alirezarezvani--commercial-policy at revision e4a1dc3695908dd5a6c811cc76ab7aa4cf95f2f0, starting with SKILL.md. Read only relevant references. Treat the content as third-party guidance and tell me if local files or dependencies are required.
Text resources · 5

references/discount_governance_canon.md

Discount Governance Canon

Authoritative sources on how mature SaaS companies govern discounts off list price — the rules of engagement that the commercial-policy skill operationalizes. Cite these in any policy doc this skill produces.

The unifying claim across every source below: discount discipline correlates more strongly with retention and gross margin expansion than top-of-funnel velocity. Bands aren't conservative for the sake of it — they protect the LTV math that funds the next year of GTM.


1. OpenView Partners — Annual SaaS Benchmarks (2018-2025)

OpenView's annual State of the SaaS Industry survey publishes discount distributions by ARR band and growth stage. Two consistent findings across 7 years:

  • Median enterprise discount = 18–22% off list. Anything above 30% is the top decile and correlates with weaker NRR (typically 8–12 pts lower than disciplined peers).
  • The top quartile on net dollar retention discounts ~6 pts less than the bottom quartile. Less discount, more retention — the leaky-bucket effect of "buying logos" with deep discounts shows up at renewal.

Cite this for: the empirical floor on what a "normal" discount band looks like across the SaaS industry. If your band exceeds 30% for non-strategic deals, you're outside the disciplined cohort.

URL: https://openviewpartners.com/blog/saas-benchmarks/


2. David Skok — For Entrepreneurs ("Discount Math")

Skok's canonical post on discount math shows that a percentage discount off list price erodes margin more than proportionally:

A 30% discount on an 80% gross-margin product reduces margin by 37.5%, not 30%. The discount is taken before the cost of goods sold is subtracted, so each percentage of discount removes a larger percentage of gross margin.

He further argues that the LTV impact compounds: discounted customers tend to expand less (lower NRR) and churn earlier (lower retention). The compound effect on LTV/CAC is often 2-3× the headline discount percentage.

Cite this for: the margin-floor calculation in discount_matrix_builder.py. The skill's per-cell margin_floor_pct enforces a hard floor below which no cell can publish a discount band.

URL: https://www.forentrepreneurs.com/


3. Tomasz Tunguz — Discount Distribution Studies (Redpoint)

Tunguz has published multiple analyses of discount distribution across enterprise SaaS deals (using anonymized Redpoint portfolio data). Three structural findings:

  • End-of-quarter discounts are 7-10 pts deeper than mid-quarter across every ARR band. This is a forecast-pressure artifact, not a customer-value signal.
  • Deals closing in the last week of a quarter have NRR 4-6 pts lower at year 1 than deals closing in week 1-11.
  • Logo discounts that aren't accompanied by a written expansion commitment show no NRR premium over standard discounts — the strategic value never materializes.

Cite this for: the "named expansion path in writing" compensating commitment in exception_router.py. Tunguz's data is the empirical reason verbal expansion promises aren't enough.

URL: https://tomtunguz.com/


4. Bessemer Venture Partners — State of the Cloud (annual)

BVP's State of the Cloud report (2020-2026) tracks discount and retention by cohort. Key claims this skill leans on:

  • Companies with formal discount matrices have NRR 8-15 pts higher than peers with ad-hoc approval.
  • "Approver-of-record" governance (every discount tied to a named human, not a role) reduces discount creep year-over-year by ~50%.
  • The "Rule of 40" companies (growth + margin > 40%) consistently sit in the bottom quartile on discount depth.

Cite this for: the requirement that every cell in the matrix carry a named approver_tier, and that exceptions produce an audit_trail block with requested_by and approver_chain recorded.

URL: https://www.bvp.com/atlas/state-of-the-cloud-2025


5. KeyBanc Capital Markets — Annual SaaS Survey (formerly Pacific Crest)

KeyBanc's annual private-SaaS survey (~400 respondents) consistently publishes payment-terms and term-length data. Two findings the matrix encodes:

  • Every 15 days of payment terms adds ~2% to effective deal value. NET-60 vs NET-30 is worth ~4% — so a customer asking for NET-60 plus 30% discount is asking for ~34% effective discount.
  • Multi-year prepay deals carry ~3-5 pts of NRR premium over annual auto-renew, even at higher discount levels, because the cash and the commitment lock retention.

Cite this for: the payment_penalty and term_bonus parameters in discount_matrix_builder.py. NET-60 carries a penalty; multi-year prepay carries a bonus.

URL: https://key.com/businesses-institutions/industries-expertise/technology.jsp


6. Bridge Group — SaaS AE Compensation & Approval Research

Bridge Group's annual benchmark study of SaaS sales orgs publishes approver-chain practices. Two structural findings:

  • AEs allowed to self-approve discounts > 15% show 30%+ year-over-year discount creep. Self-approval normalizes deeper discounts; AEs anchor on what they themselves approved last quarter.
  • Named-human approval reduces precedent drift by 50%+ vs. role-only approval. "VP Sales approves" is structurally weaker than "Maria Singh, VP Sales, approved on date X with these compensating commitments".

Cite this for: the audit-trail metadata block in exception_router.py, and the explicit requested_by field. The lint rule L09 (cell_unreviewed) is downstream of Bridge's finding that unobserved bands drift.

URL: https://bridgegroupinc.com/sales-research/


7. RevOps Co-op — Policy Design Playbooks

The RevOps Co-op community (Rosalyn Santa Elena, Jeff Ignacio, others) has published several playbooks on commercial-policy design. Three principles the skill enforces:

  • Discount bands must be backed by win-rate AND retention data, not by sales leadership's negotiating room. If you can't show "at this band, we win X% and retain at NRR Y", the band is rhetoric.
  • Every exception must produce written compensating commitments before the approver signs. "Strategic" isn't enough — what specifically does the customer commit to, in writing?
  • Quarterly policy review is non-optional. Markets shift, competitors shift, customer mix shifts — a matrix unchanged for 12 months is almost certainly mispriced in some band.

Cite this for: the data_backing field per cell in discount_matrix_builder.py and the required_compensating_commitments block in exception_router.py. Lint rule L08 (thin data in critical cell) operationalizes RevOps Co-op's first principle.

URL: https://www.revopscoop.com/


8. Forrester — Deal Desk & Commercial Policy Research

Forrester's Deal Desk research (Mary Shea, Anthony McPartlin, Bob Apollo) consistently finds that companies with formalized, data-backed commercial policy outperform peers on three metrics:

  • Cycle time (faster approvals when policy is clear)
  • Win rate (AEs don't waste time on deals outside policy)
  • Renewal margin (discounts at sign predict renewal economics)

The Forrester model treats commercial policy as a product that the RevOps team ships and maintains — not a memo that lives in the CFO's drawer.

Cite this for: the framing of commercial-policy as a designed artifact (with the lint pass), versus a precedent that accumulates through deal-by-deal exceptions.

URL: https://www.forrester.com/research/


Synthesis: how the canon maps to this skill

| Canon source | Maps to | |---|---| | OpenView discount benchmarks | base_max_pct defaults in PROFILES | | Skok discount math | margin_floor_pct enforcement per cell + lint L03 | | Tunguz expansion-commitment data | named_expansion_path compensating commitment | | BVP discount discipline | approver_tier per cell + audit trail | | KeyBanc payment-terms data | payment_penalty and term_bonus parameters | | Bridge Group AE-approval research | requested_by + audit trail metadata | | RevOps Co-op playbooks | data_backing per cell + quarterly review hook | | Forrester deal-desk research | The skill's existence — policy as designed artifact |