references/google-ads.md · 24000
/ double implementation** (COMMON): snippet on every page; thank-you reload recounts (Count=Every); hardcoded gtag AND GTM tag both firing; website tag AND imported GA4 key event both Primary.
Category C - Click ID / attribution chain broken
- C1. Auto-tagging disabled (COMMON): tag verified, conversions near zero; no gclid in landing URLs; GA4 shows Ads traffic as organic.
- C2. gclid stripped by redirects (VERY COMMON, invisible): http→https, non-www→www, trailing slash, geo redirects, shorteners. Test:
curl -IL "https://landingpage?gclid=TEST123"and watch each hop. Fix: final URLs in ads, or forward query strings (Apache QSA, Nginx$is_args$args). - C3. Conversion Linker missing (COMMON in GTM setups): no
_gcl_awcookie; heavy undercount especially Safari. - C4. Cross-domain journey (COMMON):
_gcl_awscoped to first domain. Fix: Linker cross-domain linking or pass gclid in URL. - C5. gclid mutated (RARE): CMS/scripts lowercase or truncate the gclid - Google treats as different ID.
- C6. No ad click in the test path (COMMON false alarm): website conversions only count after an ad click. Direct test submissions never appear in Ads.
Category D - Consent & privacy
- D1. Consent Mode misconfigured (VERY COMMON in EEA/UK): conversions drop 30-90% after CMP install; CMP never flips ad_storage/ad_user_data to granted. Confirm: Tag Assistant Consent tab;
gcs=G100persisting after accept. Since March 2024 Google requires ad_user_data/ad_personalization for EEA; stricter enforcement from July 2025 has been widely reported (not a formal Google announcement). - D2. Consent denied traffic + modeling gaps: denied conversions dropped or modeled; Ads and GA4 model independently. URL passthrough (
url_passthrough: true) partially recovers. - D3. Ad blockers / ITP baseline loss (ALWAYS PRESENT): typically 10–30% never track client-side, depending on audience. Mitigate with enhanced conversions / server-side.
Category E - Account configuration
- E1. Action set to Secondary (VERY COMMON confusion): only counts in "All conversions", not "Conversions"; doesn't drive Smart Bidding. Inverse: two Primaries for same event = double counting.
- E2. Conversion window too short / lag misread (COMMON): conversions back-dated to click date; recent days fill in retroactively; processing hours to 72h (gbraid/wbraid); GA4 imports +1-2 days. Don't judge the last 3 days.
- E3. Count Every vs One (COMMON): leads should be One.
- E4. Campaign-level goal exclusions: campaign uses custom goals excluding the action.
Category F - GA4-imported conversions
- F1. GA4 key event not imported (VERY COMMON): not marked Key event, never imported, accounts not linked, or data-sharing disabled. Import only counts forward.
- F2. GA4 vs Ads numbers "don't match" (CONSTANT, not a bug): click-date vs event-date, double counting when both Primary, different attribution models, Ads counts view-through/cross-device, separate consent modeling, lag, timezone. 10-30% divergence is normal. Pick ONE source of truth per action; demote the other to Secondary.
Category G - Offline / CRM imports & enhanced conversions
- G1. Upload errors: "identifiers too old" (gclid 90d), "click too recent" (wait ~6h), "invalid conversion time" (timezone bugs), "unknown click" (malformed gclid, Excel mangling, wrong account, auto-tagging off at click time), "conversion action not found" (must be source Import from clicks), unhashed/badly formatted user data (lowercase emails, E.164 phones, SHA-256).
- G2. gclid never captured into the CRM (VERY COMMON root failure): no hidden field, or reads URL only (lost on multi-page journeys - read from
_gcl_awcookie), multi-step forms dropping it. - G3. Enhanced conversions (web) not providing user_data (COMMON): EC enabled but no user_data mapping; broken CSS selectors; format errors. Verify Tag Assistant shows hashed
em/pnon the ping. - G4. Enhanced conversions for leads misconfigured (COMMON): tag must capture hashed email/phone at submit; upload same normalized identifiers later; failure points: terms not accepted, wrong action source, non-normalized uploads.
- G5. Lead form assets (Google-hosted): conversions counted natively; leads sit in Ads 30 days unless webhook/CRM integration delivers them. Website tags irrelevant to these.
Category H - Phone-call conversions
Google forwarding number or website call conversions (number swap). Failures: number hardcoded as image/formatted differently so swap fails; call trackers (CallRail) replacing after Google's snippet; minimum call length filters.
Part B.4: Ranked prevalence
- Tag/trigger never fires for the real form flow (B1/B2/B4)
- Tag removed or GTM unpublished after site changes (A2/A3)
- Secondary vs Primary / column misreading (E1)
- Consent Mode misconfiguration post-CMP (D1)
- gclid chain broken (C1-C3)
- Wrong ID/label or wrong account (A4/A5)
- GA4-import confusion and mismatch panic (F1/F2)
- Timing misreads (E2)
- Duplicate counting (B6)
- Offline/EC import failures (G1-G4) - lower volume, highest per-case complexity
Part B.5: Suggested audit order
- Account surface first: statuses + last-detected dates; Primary/Secondary; counts; windows; auto-tagging; campaign goals; Diagnostics; segment by action
- Date correlation: flatline date vs deploys/GTM versions/CMP installs
- Page source: AW-/GTM- on landing + thank-you pages; duplicates; consent defaults
- Live walk:
?gclid=TEST→ redirect survival →_gcl_aw→ submit → conversion ping + gcs value; Tag Assistant - Attribution back-end: GA4 link/import; CRM gclid capture; upload errors; EC diagnostics
- Only then conclude "tracking is fine, the campaign just isn't converting"
Key sources: support.google.com/google-ads (answers 7548399, 15629968, 13321563, 11956168, 15713840, 10989978), analyticsmania.com (28 reasons; form triggers; conversion linker), adalysis.com top-10 mistakes, adnanagic.com gclid redirects, ppc.land consent mode v2 enforcement, nicelookingdata.com GA4 vs Ads, conversiontracking.io iframes, cometly.com, tagfly.io, freak.marketing inactive tags, playhouse.digital gclid hidden field, pemavor.com offline imports.