references/management-review-guide.md
Management Review Guide
ISO 13485 Clause 5.6 management review requirements, inputs, outputs, and action tracking.
Table of Contents
- Review Requirements
- Required Inputs
- Review Agenda
- Required Outputs
- Action Tracking
- Documentation Templates
Review Requirements
ISO 13485:2016 Clause 5.6
| Requirement | Specification | |-------------|---------------| | Frequency | Planned intervals (typically quarterly or semi-annually) | | Participants | Top management involvement required | | Documentation | Records must be maintained | | Inputs | All required inputs must be reviewed | | Outputs | Decisions and actions documented |
Review Schedule
| Review Type | Frequency | Focus | Participants | |-------------|-----------|-------|--------------| | Full Management Review | Semi-annual or Annual | Complete QMS performance | CEO, QMR, all department heads | | Quarterly Quality Review | Quarterly | Key metrics and actions | QMR, Quality team, affected managers | | Monthly Quality Update | Monthly | Operational metrics | QMR, Quality team leads |
Planning Checklist
- [ ] Review date scheduled and communicated
- [ ] Previous review actions status updated
- [ ] All input data collected and analyzed
- [ ] Presentation/report prepared
- [ ] Attendee availability confirmed
- [ ] Meeting room and resources arranged
- [ ] Agenda distributed 1 week in advance
Required Inputs
ISO 13485 Required Input Topics
| Input | Source | Data Period | Responsible | |-------|--------|-------------|-------------| | Audit results | Internal and external audits | Since last review | QA Manager | | Customer feedback | Complaints, surveys, returns | Since last review | Customer Quality | | Process performance | Process metrics, yields | Since last review | Process owners | | Product conformity | Inspection data, NCRs | Since last review | QC Manager | | CAPA status | Open/closed CAPAs | Current status | CAPA Officer | | Previous review actions | Action item tracker | Since last review | QMR | | Changes to QMS | Regulatory, standard changes | Since last review | RA Manager | | Recommendations | Improvement opportunities | Ongoing collection | All managers |
Input Data Collection Template
MANAGEMENT REVIEW INPUT SUMMARY
Review Period: [Start Date] to [End Date]
Prepared By: [Name]
Date Prepared: [Date]
1. AUDIT RESULTS
Internal Audits Completed: [Number]
External Audits Completed: [Number]
Major Findings: [Number] | Minor Findings: [Number]
Open Audit Actions: [Number]
Summary: [Brief narrative]
2. CUSTOMER FEEDBACK
Total Complaints: [Number]
Complaint Rate: [X per 1000 units]
Customer Satisfaction Score: [Score]
Top Complaint Categories:
- [Category 1]: [Count]
- [Category 2]: [Count]
Trend: [Improving/Stable/Declining]
3. PROCESS PERFORMANCE
| Process | Target | Actual | Status |
|---------|--------|--------|--------|
| [Process 1] | [Target] | [Actual] | [Met/Not Met] |
4. PRODUCT CONFORMITY
First Pass Yield: [%]
Nonconformance Rate: [%]
Reject/Scrap Cost: [$]
Top NC Categories:
- [Category 1]: [Count]
5. CAPA STATUS
Open CAPAs: [Number]
Overdue CAPAs: [Number]
Effectiveness Rate: [%]
Average Closure Time: [Days]
6. PREVIOUS ACTIONS
Total Actions from Last Review: [Number]
Completed: [Number] | In Progress: [Number] | Overdue: [Number]
7. QMS CHANGES
Regulatory Changes: [List]
Standard Updates: [List]
Internal Changes: [List]
8. RECOMMENDATIONS
[List improvement opportunities collected]
Data Analysis Guidelines
| Input | Analysis Required | Red Flags | |-------|------------------|-----------| | Audit results | Trend by area, repeat findings | Major NC in same area twice | | Complaints | Pareto analysis, rate trending | Increasing rate, safety issues | | Process performance | Control charts, capability | Out of control, Cpk <1.33 | | Product conformity | Defect Pareto, yield trending | Declining yield, new defect types | | CAPA | Aging analysis, effectiveness | >10% overdue, <80% effective |
Review Agenda
Standard Agenda Template
MANAGEMENT REVIEW AGENDA
Date: [Date]
Time: [Start] - [End]
Location: [Room/Virtual Link]
Chair: [QMR Name]
1. OPENING (10 min)
- Call to order and attendance
- Approval of previous meeting minutes
- Review of previous action items
2. QMS PERFORMANCE (30 min)
- Audit results summary
- Process performance metrics
- Product conformity data
- Customer feedback analysis
3. COMPLIANCE STATUS (20 min)
- Regulatory compliance status
- Certification status
- Changes affecting QMS
4. CAPA AND IMPROVEMENT (20 min)
- CAPA status and trends
- Improvement initiatives status
- Recommendations for improvement
5. RESOURCE REVIEW (15 min)
- Resource adequacy assessment
- Training and competency status
- Infrastructure needs
6. STRATEGIC ITEMS (15 min)
- Quality objectives progress
- Quality policy adequacy
- Strategic quality initiatives
7. DECISIONS AND ACTIONS (15 min)
- Decisions required
- New action items
- Next review planning
8. CLOSING (5 min)
- Summary of decisions
- Action item review
- Adjournment
Time Allocation by Review Type
| Review Type | Duration | Focus Areas | |-------------|----------|-------------| | Full Annual Review | 3-4 hours | All inputs, strategic planning | | Semi-annual Review | 2-3 hours | All inputs, trend analysis | | Quarterly Review | 1.5-2 hours | Key metrics, action tracking |
Required Outputs
ISO 13485 Required Output Topics
| Output | Description | Documentation | |--------|-------------|---------------| | Improvement decisions | QMS and process improvements | Action items with owners | | Resource decisions | Changes to resource allocation | Resource plan updates | | Quality objectives | Changes to objectives or targets | Updated objectives document | | QMS changes | Decisions on system modifications | Change requests initiated |
Output Documentation Template
MANAGEMENT REVIEW OUTPUTS
Review Date: [Date]
Review Type: [Annual/Semi-annual/Quarterly]
DECISIONS MADE:
1. QMS IMPROVEMENT DECISIONS
| Decision | Rationale | Owner | Due Date |
|----------|-----------|-------|----------|
| [Decision 1] | [Why] | [Who] | [When] |
2. RESOURCE DECISIONS
| Decision | Resources Required | Budget Impact | Owner |
|----------|-------------------|----------------|-------|
| [Decision 1] | [What needed] | [$] | [Who] |
3. QUALITY OBJECTIVES
| Objective | Current | Target | Change | Rationale |
|-----------|---------|--------|--------|-----------|
| [Objective 1] | [Current target] | [New target] | [+/-] | [Why] |
4. QMS CHANGES APPROVED
| Change | Scope | Implementation Date | Owner |
|--------|-------|---------------------|-------|
| [Change 1] | [Affected areas] | [Date] | [Who] |
CONCLUSIONS:
- Overall QMS effectiveness: [Effective/Needs Improvement]
- Quality policy adequacy: [Adequate/Needs Update]
- Quality objectives progress: [On Track/Behind/Ahead]
NEXT REVIEW:
Date: [Date]
Special Focus Areas: [Areas requiring attention]
Action Tracking
Action Item Format
ACTION ITEM
ID: MR-[Year]-[Number]
Source: Management Review [Date]
Category: [ ] Improvement [ ] Resource [ ] Compliance [ ] Other
Description: [Specific action to be taken]
Owner: [Name, Title]
Due Date: [Date]
Priority: [ ] High [ ] Medium [ ] Low
Success Criteria: [How completion will be verified]
Resources Required: [People, budget, equipment]
Dependencies: [Other actions or conditions]
Status Updates:
| Date | Update | Updated By |
|------|--------|------------|
| [Date] | [Progress note] | [Name] |
Completion:
Completed Date: [Date]
Evidence: [Reference to evidence of completion]
Verified By: [Name, Date]
Action Status Categories
| Status | Definition | Color Code | |--------|------------|------------| | Not Started | Assigned but work not begun | Gray | | In Progress | Work underway | Blue | | On Hold | Blocked, awaiting dependency | Yellow | | Overdue | Past due date, not complete | Red | | Complete | Finished, pending verification | Green | | Verified | Completion verified | Dark Green | | Cancelled | No longer required | Strikethrough |
Action Tracking Dashboard
MANAGEMENT REVIEW ACTION TRACKER
Review: [Date]
Last Updated: [Date]
SUMMARY:
Total Actions: [Number]
| Status | Count | % |
|--------|-------|---|
| Complete/Verified | [N] | [%] |
| In Progress | [N] | [%] |
| Not Started | [N] | [%] |
| Overdue | [N] | [%] |
| On Hold | [N] | [%] |
OVERDUE ACTIONS (Requires Escalation):
| ID | Description | Owner | Due Date | Days Overdue |
|----|-------------|-------|----------|--------------|
| [ID] | [Brief] | [Name] | [Date] | [Days] |
UPCOMING DUE (Next 30 Days):
| ID | Description | Owner | Due Date |
|----|-------------|-------|----------|
| [ID] | [Brief] | [Name] | [Date] |
Documentation Templates
Meeting Minutes Template
MANAGEMENT REVIEW MEETING MINUTES
Date: [Date]
Time: [Start] - [End]
Location: [Location]
Chair: [Name]
Recorder: [Name]
ATTENDEES:
| Name | Title | Present |
|------|-------|---------|
| [Name] | [Title] | ☑ Yes / ☐ No |
AGENDA ITEMS REVIEWED:
1. [Topic]
Discussion: [Summary of discussion]
Decision: [Decision made, if any]
Action: [Action assigned, if any]
2. [Topic]
...
DECISIONS SUMMARY:
1. [Decision 1]
2. [Decision 2]
ACTIONS ASSIGNED:
| ID | Action | Owner | Due Date |
|----|--------|-------|----------|
| MR-XX-01 | [Action] | [Name] | [Date] |
NEXT MEETING:
Date: [Date]
Preliminary Agenda Items: [Topics to cover]
APPROVAL:
Chair: _________________ Date: _______
QMR: _________________ Date: _______
Review Effectiveness Metrics
| Metric | Target | Calculation | |--------|--------|-------------| | Action completion rate | >90% | Completed on time / Total actions | | Review attendance | 100% required | Required attendees present / Required | | Input completeness | 100% | Inputs provided / Required inputs | | Decision documentation | 100% | Documented decisions / Decisions made | | Time to complete review | Per schedule | Actual date - Planned date |