references/metrics.md
Technology Evaluation Metrics
Detailed metrics and calculations used in technology stack evaluation.
Table of Contents
- Scoring and Comparison
- Financial Calculations
- Ecosystem Health Metrics
- Security Metrics
- Migration Metrics
- Performance Benchmarks
Scoring and Comparison
Technology Comparison Matrix
| Metric | Scale | Description | |--------|-------|-------------| | Feature Completeness | 0-100 | Coverage of required features | | Learning Curve | Easy/Medium/Hard | Time to developer proficiency | | Developer Experience | 0-100 | Tooling, debugging, workflow quality | | Documentation Quality | 0-10 | Completeness, clarity, examples |
Weighted Scoring Algorithm
The comparator uses normalized weighted scoring:
# Default category weights (sum to 100%)
weights = {
"performance": 15,
"scalability": 15,
"developer_experience": 20,
"ecosystem": 15,
"learning_curve": 10,
"documentation": 10,
"community_support": 10,
"enterprise_readiness": 5
}
# Final score calculation
weighted_score = sum(category_score * weight / 100 for each category)
Confidence Scoring
Confidence is calculated based on score gap between top options:
| Score Gap | Confidence Level | |-----------|------------------| | < 5 points | Low (40-50%) | | 5-15 points | Medium (50-70%) | | > 15 points | High (70-100%) |
Financial Calculations
TCO Components
Initial Costs (One-Time)
- Licensing fees
- Training:
team_size * hours_per_dev * hourly_rate + materials - Migration costs
- Setup and tooling
Operational Costs (Annual)
- Licensing renewals
- Hosting:
base_cost * (1 + growth_rate)^(year - 1) - Support contracts
- Maintenance:
team_size * hours_per_dev_monthly * hourly_rate * 12
Scaling Costs
- Infrastructure:
servers * cost_per_server * 12 - Cost per user:
total_yearly_cost / user_count
ROI Calculations
productivity_value = additional_features_per_year * avg_feature_value
net_tco = total_cost - (productivity_value * years)
roi_percentage = (benefits - costs) / costs * 100
Cost Per Metric Reference
| Metric | Description | |--------|-------------| | Cost per user | Monthly or yearly per active user | | Cost per API request | Average cost per 1000 requests | | Cost per GB | Storage and transfer costs | | Cost per compute hour | Processing time costs |
Ecosystem Health Metrics
GitHub Health Score (0-100)
| Metric | Max Points | Thresholds | |--------|------------|------------| | Stars | 30 | 50K+: 30, 20K+: 25, 10K+: 20, 5K+: 15, 1K+: 10 | | Forks | 20 | 10K+: 20, 5K+: 15, 2K+: 12, 1K+: 10 | | Contributors | 20 | 500+: 20, 200+: 15, 100+: 12, 50+: 10 | | Commits/month | 30 | 100+: 30, 50+: 25, 25+: 20, 10+: 15 |
npm Health Score (0-100)
| Metric | Max Points | Thresholds | |--------|------------|------------| | Weekly downloads | 40 | 1M+: 40, 500K+: 35, 100K+: 30, 50K+: 25, 10K+: 20 | | Major version | 20 | v5+: 20, v3+: 15, v1+: 10 | | Dependencies | 20 | ≤10: 20, ≤25: 15, ≤50: 10 (fewer is better) | | Days since publish | 20 | ≤30: 20, ≤90: 15, ≤180: 10, ≤365: 5 |
Community Health Score (0-100)
| Metric | Max Points | Thresholds | |--------|------------|------------| | Stack Overflow questions | 25 | 50K+: 25, 20K+: 20, 10K+: 15, 5K+: 10 | | Job postings | 25 | 5K+: 25, 2K+: 20, 1K+: 15, 500+: 10 | | Tutorials | 25 | 1K+: 25, 500+: 20, 200+: 15, 100+: 10 | | Forum/Discord members | 25 | 50K+: 25, 20K+: 20, 10K+: 15, 5K+: 10 |
Corporate Backing Score
| Backing Type | Score | |--------------|-------| | Major tech company (Google, Microsoft, Meta) | 100 | | Established company (Vercel, HashiCorp) | 80 | | Funded startup | 60 | | Community-led (strong community) | 40 | | Individual maintainers | 20 |
Security Metrics
Security Scoring Components
| Metric | Description | |--------|-------------| | CVE Count (12 months) | Known vulnerabilities in last year | | CVE Count (3 years) | Longer-term vulnerability history | | Severity Distribution | Critical/High/Medium/Low counts | | Patch Frequency | Average days to patch vulnerabilities |
Compliance Readiness Levels
| Level | Score Range | Description | |-------|-------------|-------------| | Ready | 90-100% | Meets compliance requirements | | Mostly Ready | 70-89% | Minor gaps to address | | Partial | 50-69% | Significant work needed | | Not Ready | < 50% | Major gaps exist |
Compliance Framework Coverage
GDPR
- Data privacy features
- Consent management
- Data portability
- Right to deletion
SOC2
- Access controls
- Encryption at rest/transit
- Audit logging
- Change management
HIPAA
- PHI handling
- Encryption standards
- Access controls
- Audit trails
Migration Metrics
Complexity Scoring (1-10 Scale)
| Factor | Weight | Description | |--------|--------|-------------| | Code Changes | 30% | Lines of code affected | | Architecture Impact | 25% | Breaking changes, API compatibility | | Data Migration | 25% | Schema changes, data transformation | | Downtime Requirements | 20% | Zero-downtime possible vs planned outage |
Effort Estimation
| Phase | Components | |-------|------------| | Development | Hours per component * complexity factor | | Testing | Unit + integration + E2E hours | | Training | Team size * learning curve hours | | Buffer | 20-30% for unknowns |
Risk Assessment Matrix
| Risk Category | Factors Evaluated | |---------------|-------------------| | Technical | API incompatibilities, performance regressions | | Business | Downtime impact, feature parity gaps | | Team | Learning curve, skill gaps |
Performance Benchmarks
Throughput/Latency Metrics
| Metric | Description | |--------|-------------| | RPS | Requests per second | | Avg Response Time | Mean response latency (ms) | | P95 Latency | 95th percentile response time | | P99 Latency | 99th percentile response time | | Concurrent Users | Maximum simultaneous connections |
Resource Usage Metrics
| Metric | Unit | |--------|------| | Memory | MB/GB per instance | | CPU | Utilization percentage | | Storage | GB required | | Network | Bandwidth MB/s |
Scalability Characteristics
| Type | Description | |------|-------------| | Horizontal | Add more instances, efficiency factor | | Vertical | CPU/memory limits per instance | | Cost per Performance | Dollar per 1000 RPS | | Scaling Inflection | Point where cost efficiency changes |