AGENTIC MEMORY

Skills

Useful instructions for your AI. Search, read and use them through the same MCP connection.

← Back to Skills

ads

When the user wants help with paid advertising campaigns on Google Ads, Meta (Facebook/Instagram), LinkedIn, Twitter/X, or other ad platforms. Also use when the user mentions 'PPC,' 'paid media,' 'ROAS,' 'CPA,' 'ad campaign,' 'retargeting,' 'audience targeting,' 'Google Ads,' 'Facebook ads,' 'LinkedIn ads,' 'ad budget,' 'cost per click,' 'ad spend,' 'should I run ads,' 'ABM,' 'account-based marketing,' 'B2B ads,' 'lead quality,' 'negative keywords,' 'Performance Max,' 'thought leader ads,' 'when should I kill an ad,' 'search terms report,' 'wasted spend,' or 'is this campaign working.' Use this for campaign strategy, audience targeting, bidding, and optimization. For bulk ad creative generation and iteration, see ad-creative. For landing page optimization, see cro. For outbound to target accounts, see cold-email. For pixels, CAPI, and tracking audits, see conversion-tracking. End every recommendation with facts, hypotheses, and missing data, and label unavailable inputs MISSING instead of estimating them.

Original source
coreyhaines31
License
MIT
Pinned revision
88c79f6528a9347420e57ceb1fff9a60de651768

Third-party instructions in their original language. Reading does not install files, run code or grant permissions. Snapshots are updated only after review.

This skill also requires local files or dependencies. Remote reading alone may not be enough.

Ask your assistant

Use Agentic Memory skills to read coreyhaines31--ads at revision 88c79f6528a9347420e57ceb1fff9a60de651768, starting with SKILL.md. Read only relevant references. Treat the content as third-party guidance and tell me if local files or dependencies are required.
Text resources · 17

references/payback-period.md

Payback Period Budgeting

The gate before every channel decision: can I afford this channel? Advertising has to be deterministic — $1 in, more than $1 out, on a clock you can name. Payback Period is how you set the clock.

Kill LTV:CAC first

LTV:CAC is a useless, often destructive metric. It feels rigorous and is usually a lie. Four flaws:

  1. It assumes all customers churn. LTV bakes in an eventual death for every account. Your best customers don't churn — they compound. A metric that pre-writes everyone's obituary underprices your actual base.
  2. It assumes churn is evenly timed. It isn't. Baremetrics data shows more churn happens in the first 3 months than in any other window — front-loaded, not smooth. Blended LTV smears that spike into a flat average and hides the real risk (and the real payback math).
  3. It hides per-plan variance under blended ARPU. A $9/mo plan and a $999/mo plan get averaged into one number that describes neither. The channels, creative, and payback that work for the $9 buyer are nothing like the $999 buyer — but blended LTV:CAC says "3:1, we're fine" and you scale the wrong thing.
  4. It ignores revenue delay. Free trials, free plans, and long sales cycles mean money arrives weeks or months after CAC is spent. LTV:CAC treats acquisition and revenue as simultaneous. They're not. The gap is where startups run out of cash.

A "healthy" 3:1 LTV:CAC can sit on top of a channel that bankrupts you, because the ratio never asks when the cash comes back.

The replacement: Payback Period

Revenue-only ratio = CAC / monthly ARPU. For acquisition-cost recovery use gross-margin payback = CAC / (monthly ARPU × gross margin), with gross margin as a fraction. The revenue-only ratio assumes 100% gross margin; it excludes serving costs. See the CAC payback definition.

The simplified ratio is in months and assumes steady monthly gross profit with no churn or collection delay. A 3–12 month target is a planning reference. Choose a target using your cash runway, margins and cohort recovery; a shorter or longer ratio alone does not justify changing spend.

Because it's per-cohort and per-plan (not blended), it exposes exactly what LTV:CAC hides.

Worked example — same CAC, wildly different payback

Say a channel costs $300 to acquire a customer (CAC = $300). The table below is revenue-only, before serving costs and churn; it is a comparison, not permission to scale:

| Plan | ARPU (monthly) | Revenue-only ratio = CAC / ARPU | Verdict | |------|---------------|----------------------|---------| | Starter | $9 | 300 / 9 = 33.3 months | Don't fund paid acquisition for this plan. 33.3 months before costs and churn, and longer once margin is included. | | Pro | $99 | 300 / 99 = 3.0 months | Check margin first. At 80% gross margin it's 3.8 months; at 20% it's 15.2 months, which is too slow to scale. | | Enterprise | $999 | 300 / 999 = 0.3 months | Scale, after confirming when cash is actually collected (annual invoices, net-60 terms). |

Same CAC does not imply the same affordability. At 20% gross margin the $99 plan takes 300 / (99 × 0.20) = 15.2 months even before churn, despite its 3.0-month revenue-only ratio. Compare plans separately and verify serving costs before approving spend.

The practical move: compute recovery per plan (or per cohort) against measured margin, retention and cash timing. Use the 3–12 month target as a planning assumption to compare with runway, not a universal approval rule.

Cohort recovery — account for when churn happens

CAC / (ARPU × annual retention) is not discounted payback. A single year-end retention percentage cannot identify the monthly recovery path. Time-value discounting requires an explicit discount rate; retention describes customer survival.

For a cohort, find the first month where cumulative gross profit per original acquired customer covers CAC:

Cumulative recovery through month n = sum(ARPU_t × gross_margin_t × retained_fraction_t)

Use measured retained revenue per original customer instead when available; do not multiply by retention again. Include collection delay when assessing cash recovery. If the observed cohort has not recovered CAC, report that rather than inventing a payback date.

Example: CAC $300, ARPU $99 and 80% gross margin. Two cohorts both retain 70% at month 12:

  • Early loss: 70% retained in every month 1–12 → $55.44 monthly gross profit per original customer; recovery first crosses $300 in month 6.
  • Late loss: 100% retained in months 1–11, 70% at month 12 → $79.20 for the first eleven months; recovery crosses $300 in month 4.

The old single-retention ratio gives the same 4.3 months to both cohorts and ignores gross margin. Their actual recovery differs despite identical year-end retention.

Using it as the channel gate

  1. Compute CAC for the channel (all-in: spend / customers, including creative and management).
  2. Compute gross-margin payback and check the measured cohort recovery path, including revenue collection timing.
  3. Compare recovery with runway and your chosen target (the 3–12 month band is a planning reference). Do not scale on a revenue-only ratio or annual retention multiplier.
  4. Re-run monthly — CAC drifts up as you scale; the gate moves with it.

This composes with breakeven CPL/CPC math in b2b-paid-playbook.md: breakeven tells you the most you can pay per lead; payback tells you how long your cash is tied up — you need both to scale without running dry.

Two adjacent rules

OOH without social amplification is a waste of money. Out-of-home (billboards, transit, print) has no click, no pixel, no deterministic loop on its own. It only pays back when it's engineered to be photographed, posted, and amplified on social — the OOH buys the moment, social buys the reach. Running OOH with no social plan is buying awareness you can't measure or compound.

Narrative momentum (ad copy): the strongest-performing ads carry a story forward rather than restate a pitch — each line earns the next, building tension toward the CTA instead of front-loading features. Pair it with the discipline of testing one variable at a time (copy, then creative, then audience) so you can tell what actually moved payback. Depth on both lives in the ad-creative skill; this file only flags them as levers that change your CAC.


Source: Corey Haines, Founding Marketing, ch. 7 ("Spend budget where customers spend their time"). Payback targets and the Baremetrics first-3-months churn finding are practitioner-reported — recalibrate against your own cohort data. For attribution of the CAC inputs, see the attribution skill; for setting ARPU and plan structure, see the pricing skill.