references/repository_and_synthesis.md
Research Repository and Synthesis
Reference for turning observations into governed insights. Pairs with insight_synthesizer.py.
Observation vs insight
The foundational discipline of ResearchOps is the distinction between an observation (a single piece of evidence — one participant did or said one thing) and an insight (a pattern that recurs across independent sources and carries an implication). Promoting an observation to an insight because it was vivid or confirmed a prior is the cardinal sin of synthesis. The synthesizer enforces a source threshold: a candidate supported by fewer than the threshold of distinct participants is labeled an ANECDOTE and is never promoted.
Atomic research
Tomer Sharon's atomic research model (and the "Polaris" repository concept) decomposes research into reusable units: Experiments → Facts (observations) → Insights → Recommendations. Facts are tagged and stored so that insights can be traced back to evidence and reused across studies. The payoff is a repository where a claim can always be drilled down to the observations that support it — and where the same evidence can support future questions.
Affinity mapping
The classic synthesis technique is affinity mapping: cluster observations into emergent themes bottom-up, then name the themes. The insight_synthesizer.py tool is a deterministic, tag-based proxy for this — it clusters by the codes you assign and ranks by cross-participant recurrence. The human still does the interpretive naming; the tool enforces the counting discipline.
Repository governance and democratization
As organizations democratize research (PMs and designers running their own studies), the repository becomes the guardrail. Governance practices: a consistent tagging taxonomy, evidence linked to every insight, a confidence field, and a review step before an insight is marked "validated." Without governance, democratized research produces a pile of unsearchable anecdotes; with it, the repository compounds in value.
Sources
- Sharon, T., Validating Product Ideas Through Lean User Research (Rosenfeld, 2016) and the atomic-research / Polaris model.
- ResearchOps Community, Research Repositories and Democratization working-group reports.
- Braun, V., & Clarke, V., Thematic Analysis: A Practical Guide (Sage, 2022).
- Beyer, H., & Holtzblatt, K., Contextual Design (1998) — affinity diagramming.
- Dovetail / EnjoyHQ practitioner guides on insight repositories and tagging taxonomies.
- Kaplan, K., Taxonomy 101 and Research Repositories — Nielsen Norman Group.