AGENTIC MEMORY

Skills

Useful instructions for your AI. Search, read and use them through the same MCP connection.

← Back to Skills

rfp-responder

Use when an RFP, RFI, RFQ or security or vendor questionnaire arrives. Parses mandatory vs weighted requirements with rfp_parser.py, drafts proof-point answers with response_drafter.py and estimates win chance with winrate_predictor.py.

Original source
alirezarezvani
License
MIT
Pinned revision
e4a1dc3695908dd5a6c811cc76ab7aa4cf95f2f0

Third-party instructions in their original language. Reading does not install files, run code or grant permissions. Snapshots are updated only after review.

This skill also requires local files or dependencies. Remote reading alone may not be enough.

Ask your assistant

Use Agentic Memory skills to read alirezarezvani--rfp-responder at revision e4a1dc3695908dd5a6c811cc76ab7aa4cf95f2f0, starting with SKILL.md. Read only relevant references. Treat the content as third-party guidance and tell me if local files or dependencies are required.
Text resources · 5

references/rfp_strategy_canon.md

RFP Strategy Canon — Industry Research on RFP Win-Rates and Buyer Behavior

This reference grounds the winrate_predictor.py factor weights in published industry research. The model is opinionated but defensible: every factor maps to a citation below.

Headline findings the skill encodes

Base win-rates are honestly grim

  • Average competitive B2B RFP win-rate: 15-25% across industries (Bain, Gartner).
  • With disciplined bid/no-bid qualification: 35-45%.
  • Without qualification: 5-12% — sales-engineering capacity burned on unwinnable pursuits.

The skill's 20% NO-BID threshold is calibrated to land below the disciplined-pursuit floor.

Incumbents win renewal RFPs 70-80% of the time

Absent a named failure event (security breach, missed SLA, executive turnover at the incumbent), incumbents win 70-80% of renewal RFPs (Forrester B2B-RFP research). This is the empirical basis for the −30% incumbent penalty when incumbent_advantage is "strong."

Late entry is structurally penalized

If you weren't part of the conversation before the RFP issued, the RFP was scoped to someone else's strengths. Forrester data: late-entry vendors win 8-12% of RFPs vs 25-35% for vendors who engaged in capture. The skill's −15% late-entry penalty is the midpoint of this gap.

Relationship strength dominates content quality at the margin

Bain: in deals where the named champion advocates internally, win-rate lifts 20-30 percentage points over the "warm but no champion" baseline. The skill's +25% champion factor is the lower bound of this range.

Decision-criteria alignment is bimodal

When buyer decision criteria align >80% with your strengths, win-rate is roughly 2x the base rate. When alignment is <50%, win-rate collapses to ~30% of base (McKinsey B2B sales research). The skill encodes this as a +10 / 0 / −10 step function rather than a continuous curve, because the bimodality is the honest reality.

Competitor count compresses win-rate predictably

  • 1 competitor (sole-source consideration): 60-80% win-rate
  • 2 competitors: 35-50%
  • 3 competitors: 20-30%
  • 4-5 competitors: 12-18%
  • 6+ competitors: 5-10%

The skill's competitor-count factor (+20 / +5 / 0 / -10 / -20) tracks this curve.

Industry profile tuning

The skill exposes 5 profiles via --profile. Each shifts the base rate:

  • enterprise-software (+5): longer sales cycles, deeper technical evaluation, but disciplined buyers reward fit-honest vendors. Base rate slightly above average.
  • saas (0): market baseline.
  • services (−5): commoditized for many engagement types, weaker differentiation moats, harder to defend price.
  • government (−15): FAR-governed, compliance-heavy, incumbent-favored, evaluation timelines extend 2-4x. Forrester / GSA data.
  • healthcare (−10): regulatory overhead (HIPAA, FDA, HITRUST), risk-averse procurement, longer pilot cycles. Gartner healthcare-vertical research.

What this skill deliberately does NOT model

  • Pricing positioning — outside scope; consume from commercial/pricing-strategist.
  • Proposal aesthetics / production quality — Shipley canon says these matter at the margin (3-5 percentage points) but never override fit, win-themes, and relationship. Skill omits.
  • Evaluator psychology — Strategic Proposals research shows evaluators score on the rubric they were given. The skill assumes the rubric is the source of truth; theme-injection happens within rubric constraints.

Sources

  1. Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR), especially Parts 14 (Sealed Bidding) and 15 (Contracting by Negotiation), at acquisition.gov/far. Governs US federal RFPs. Defines the compliance-matrix requirement, evaluation-factor disclosure rules, and proposal-format constraints that drive the "government" profile penalty.

  2. GSA (General Services Administration) RFP and procurement guidance, at gsa.gov. Quantifies federal evaluation timelines (typically 90-180 days) and the disproportionate weight federal evaluators give to past-performance citations — relevant to proof-point substantiation discipline.

  3. Forrester Research, B2B Buyer Studies — recurring annual research on B2B buying behavior. Sources the 70-80% incumbent renewal-win-rate, the late-entry penalty, and the "5-10 vendor longlist" reality of modern RFP processes.

  4. Gartner, RFP Best Practices — published guidance for IT-buyer organizations. Quantifies vendor-shortlist sizes by deal value, evaluation-cycle length by industry, and the structural advantage of fit-honest responses over feature-checklist responses.

  5. Bain & Company, B2B Sales and RFP-Win-Rate Research — Bain's commercial-discipline practice publishes regular benchmarks on disciplined-pursuit win-rates (35-45%) vs respond-to-everything win-rates (5-12%). The 20% NO-BID threshold in winrate_predictor.py is calibrated against this data.

  6. McKinsey & Company, B2B Sales Practice — McKinsey research on decision-criteria alignment and win-rate. Sources the bimodal alignment effect (>80% alignment doubles base rate; <50% collapses to 30% of base) encoded in alignment_factor().

  7. B2B International (now Kantar B2B), Buyer Behavior in RFP Processes — research on how B2B evaluation committees actually score responses. Confirms that compliance-matrix presence, proof-point substantiation, and rubric-aligned response structure are the top-3 evaluator-cited differentiators.

  8. Patrick Lencioni, Getting Naked: A Business Fable About Shedding the Three Fears That Sabotage Client Loyalty (Jossey-Bass, 2010). The "we don't have a proof point for this — here's what we'd do instead" honesty discipline that informs the skill's hard rule: surface GAPs, never invent. Lencioni's "tell the kind truth" principle operationalized as a refusal to fabricate evidence.