references/risk-assessment-guide.md
Risk Assessment Methodology Guide
Comprehensive guidance for conducting information security risk assessments per ISO 27001 Clause 6.1.2.
Table of Contents
- Risk Assessment Process
- Asset Identification
- Threat Analysis
- Vulnerability Assessment
- Risk Calculation
- Risk Treatment
- Templates and Tools
Risk Assessment Process
ISO 27001 Requirements (Clause 6.1.2)
The organization shall:
- Define risk assessment process
- Establish risk criteria (acceptance, assessment)
- Identify information security risks
- Analyze and evaluate risks
- Ensure repeatable and consistent results
Process Overview
1. Context → 2. Asset ID → 3. Threat ID → 4. Vuln ID → 5. Risk Calc → 6. Treatment
↑ |
└──────────────────── Review & Update ←───────────────────────────────┘
Asset Identification
Asset Categories
| Category | Examples | Typical Classification | |----------|----------|----------------------| | Information | Patient records, source code, contracts | Confidential-Critical | | Software | EHR systems, databases, custom apps | High-Critical | | Hardware | Servers, medical devices, network gear | High | | Services | Cloud hosting, backup, email | High | | People | Admin accounts, key personnel | Critical | | Intangibles | Reputation, intellectual property | High |
Classification Scheme
| Level | Definition | Impact if Compromised | |-------|------------|----------------------| | Critical | Business-critical, regulated data | Severe - regulatory fines, safety risk | | High | Important business data | Significant - major disruption | | Medium | Internal business data | Moderate - operational impact | | Low | Non-sensitive data | Minor - limited impact | | Public | Intended for public release | Minimal - no impact |
Asset Inventory Template
| ID | Asset Name | Type | Owner | Location | Classification | Value | |----|------------|------|-------|----------|----------------|-------| | A001 | Patient DB | Information | DBA Lead | AWS RDS | Critical | $5M | | A002 | EHR App | Software | App Team | AWS ECS | Critical | $2M | | A003 | Admin Creds | Access | Security | Vault | Critical | N/A |
Threat Analysis
Healthcare Threat Landscape
| Threat | Likelihood | Target Assets | Motivation | |--------|------------|---------------|------------| | Ransomware | High | All systems | Financial | | Data breach | High | Patient data | Financial/Competitive | | Phishing | Very High | User accounts | Access | | Insider threat | Medium | Sensitive data | Various | | DDoS | Medium | Public services | Disruption | | Supply chain | Medium | Third-party systems | Access |
Threat Modeling Approaches
STRIDE Model:
- Spoofing identity
- Tampering with data
- Repudiation
- Information disclosure
- Denial of service
- Elevation of privilege
Threat Actor Categories:
| Actor | Capability | Motivation | Typical Targets | |-------|-----------|------------|-----------------| | Nation-state | Very High | Espionage, disruption | Critical infrastructure | | Organized crime | High | Financial gain | Healthcare, finance | | Hacktivists | Medium | Ideology | Public-facing systems | | Insiders | Varies | Financial, revenge | Sensitive data | | Script kiddies | Low | Notoriety | Unpatched systems |
Vulnerability Assessment
Vulnerability Categories
| Category | Examples | Detection Method | |----------|----------|------------------| | Technical | Unpatched software, weak configs | Vulnerability scans | | Process | Missing procedures, gaps | Process audits | | People | Lack of training, social engineering | Phishing tests | | Physical | Inadequate access controls | Physical audits |
Vulnerability Scoring (CVSS Alignment)
| Score Range | Severity | Example | |-------------|----------|---------| | 9.0-10.0 | Critical | RCE without authentication | | 7.0-8.9 | High | Authentication bypass | | 4.0-6.9 | Medium | Information disclosure | | 0.1-3.9 | Low | Minor configuration issue |
Vulnerability Sources
- Automated Scans: Nessus, Qualys, OpenVAS
- Penetration Testing: Annual third-party tests
- Code Analysis: SAST/DAST tools
- Configuration Audits: CIS benchmarks
- Threat Intelligence: CVE feeds, vendor advisories
Risk Calculation
Risk Formula
Risk = Likelihood × Impact
Likelihood Scale (1-5)
| Score | Likelihood | Definition | |-------|-----------|------------| | 5 | Almost Certain | Expected to occur multiple times per year | | 4 | Likely | Expected to occur at least once per year | | 3 | Possible | Could occur within 2-3 years | | 2 | Unlikely | Could occur within 5 years | | 1 | Rare | Unlikely to occur |
Impact Scale (1-5)
| Score | Impact | Financial | Operational | Reputational | |-------|--------|-----------|-------------|--------------| | 5 | Catastrophic | >$10M | Total shutdown | International news | | 4 | Major | $1M-$10M | Major disruption | National news | | 3 | Moderate | $100K-$1M | Significant impact | Local news | | 2 | Minor | $10K-$100K | Minor disruption | Complaints | | 1 | Negligible | <$10K | Minimal impact | Internal only |
Risk Matrix
| | Impact 1 | Impact 2 | Impact 3 | Impact 4 | Impact 5 | |-----|----------|----------|----------|----------|----------| | L5 | 5 (Low) | 10 (Med) | 15 (High) | 20 (Crit) | 25 (Crit) | | L4 | 4 (Low) | 8 (Med) | 12 (Med) | 16 (High) | 20 (Crit) | | L3 | 3 (Min) | 6 (Low) | 9 (Med) | 12 (Med) | 15 (High) | | L2 | 2 (Min) | 4 (Low) | 6 (Low) | 8 (Med) | 10 (Med) | | L1 | 1 (Min) | 2 (Min) | 3 (Min) | 4 (Low) | 5 (Low) |
Risk Levels
| Level | Score Range | Action Required | |-------|-------------|-----------------| | Critical | 20-25 | Immediate action, escalate to management | | High | 15-19 | Treatment plan within 30 days | | Medium | 10-14 | Treatment plan within 90 days | | Low | 5-9 | Accept or implement low-cost controls | | Minimal | 1-4 | Accept risk, document decision |
Risk Treatment
Treatment Options (ISO 27001)
| Option | Description | When to Use | |--------|-------------|-------------| | Modify | Implement controls to reduce risk | Most risks | | Avoid | Eliminate the risk source | Unacceptable risks | | Share | Transfer via insurance/outsourcing | High financial impact | | Retain | Accept the risk | Low risks, cost-prohibitive controls |
Control Selection Criteria
- Effectiveness: Reduces likelihood or impact
- Cost: Implementation and maintenance costs
- Feasibility: Technical and operational viability
- Compliance: Meets regulatory requirements
- Integration: Works with existing controls
Residual Risk
After implementing controls:
Residual Risk = Inherent Risk × (1 - Control Effectiveness)
| Control Effectiveness | Residual Risk Factor | |----------------------|---------------------| | 90%+ | Very Low (0.1×) | | 70-89% | Low (0.2-0.3×) | | 50-69% | Moderate (0.4-0.5×) | | <50% | Limited reduction |
Templates and Tools
Risk Register Template
| Risk ID | Asset | Threat | Vulnerability | L | I | Inherent | Control | Residual | Owner | Status | |---------|-------|--------|---------------|---|---|----------|---------|----------|-------|--------| | R001 | Patient DB | Data breach | Weak encryption | 4 | 5 | 20 | AES-256 | 8 | DBA | Open | | R002 | Admin access | Credential theft | No MFA | 5 | 5 | 25 | MFA | 5 | Security | Closed |
Risk Assessment Report Sections
-
Executive Summary
- Key findings
- Critical/high risks count
- Overall risk posture
-
Methodology
- Assessment scope
- Criteria used
- Limitations
-
Asset Summary
- Asset inventory
- Classification distribution
-
Risk Findings
- Risk register
- Heat map visualization
- Trend analysis
-
Recommendations
- Priority treatments
- Timeline and resources
- Residual risk projection
-
Appendices
- Detailed asset list
- Threat catalog
- Control mapping