references/segmentation_and_ci.md
Segmentation and Competitive Intelligence
Reference for segmentation scoring and competitive-intelligence synthesis. Pairs with segmentation_scorer.py.
What makes a segment useful (Kotler)
A market segment is only useful if it meets five criteria. The scorer weights and gates them:
- Measurable — you can size and identify it.
- Substantial — it is large and profitable enough to be worth serving. (Gate: a tiny slice is not a market.)
- Accessible — you can reach it through channels you can afford. (Gate: an unreachable segment is academic.)
- Differentiable — it responds differently to your offer than other segments do; otherwise it is not a distinct segment.
- Actionable — you can design and execute a program for it.
Substantiality and accessibility are gates because they are the two that most often fail silently: teams fall in love with a precisely-described segment that is too small or has no viable channel.
Bases of segmentation
- Firmographic (B2B): industry, size, geography — easy to measure, weak at predicting behavior.
- Demographic (B2C): age, income, role — same trade-off.
- Needs-based / behavioral: grouping by the job customers are trying to get done. Stronger predictor of response, harder to measure. Christensen's Jobs-to-be-Done reframes segmentation around the progress a customer is trying to make, not who they are.
The strongest segmentations pair a needs-based core with a firmographic/demographic proxy you can actually target.
Competitive intelligence
CI synthesis is structured, ethical analysis of the competitive landscape:
- Porter's Five Forces frames structural attractiveness (rivalry, new entrants, substitutes, supplier power, buyer power).
- SCIP (Strategic and Competitive Intelligence Professionals) publishes a code of ethics: no misrepresentation of identity, no acquisition of protected/confidential information, full compliance with law. CI is built from public and ethically-obtained sources.
Advanced preference measurement
When you need to quantify trade-offs, conjoint analysis and MaxDiff (best-worst scaling) estimate the relative importance of attributes and the willingness to trade one for another — far more reliable than directly asking "how important is X?"
Sources
- Kotler, P., & Keller, K., Marketing Management, 15th ed. — segmentation criteria.
- Christensen, Hall, Dillon & Duncan, Competing Against Luck (2016) — Jobs-to-be-Done.
- Porter, M., Competitive Strategy (1980) — Five Forces.
- SCIP, Code of Ethics for CI Professionals.
- Orme, B., Getting Started with Conjoint Analysis, 4th ed. (Sawtooth, Research Publishers).
- Smith, W., Product Differentiation and Market Segmentation as Alternative Marketing Strategies — J Marketing 1956 (the founding segmentation paper).