references/sub_use_case_routing.md
Sub-Use-Case Routing — The 5 Patent Search Strategies
This reference answers exactly one decision: given the user's Q2 commitment, which search strategy / ranking heuristic / DOCX emphasis applies?
The patent skill refuses to be a generic "patent search". Q2 is mandatory. The 5 sub-use-cases use fundamentally different strategies — running a novelty search and calling it FTO produces wrong answers in dangerous ways.
Why Sub-Use-Case Commitment Matters
| Sub-use-case | Wrong-strategy danger | |---|---| | Novelty | Generic search misses claim-text proximity → false negatives ("looks novel, isn't") | | FTO | Generic search includes expired/abandoned patents → false positives ("looks blocked, isn't") | | Landscape | Generic search misses CPC class trends → incomplete competitive picture | | Diligence | Generic search misses assignment chain → ownership-verification gaps | | Litigation | Generic search includes art after priority date → useless for invalidation |
The 5 strategies are not interchangeable. The skill enforces commitment to prevent strategy mismatches.
Strategy 1: Novelty Search
Question being answered
"Am I novel enough to file? Is there art that anticipates or makes obvious my invention?"
Search emphasis
- Narrow queries on invention-specific terminology (don't drown in adjacent art)
- Claims-text focused (the legal test is claim-by-claim anticipation)
- Pre-filing date irrelevant — anything published before user's filing is potential art
Query plan
- 3 narrow Google Patents queries on invention-specific terms
- 2 broad concept queries with synonyms (Google Patents + Espacenet)
- 1 CPC class-restricted query (after class identification from initial hits)
- (Optional Lens.org) forward citations from any closest art
Total: 6-7 sequential queries.
Ranking heuristic
Rank by claim-text overlap with user's invention description (Q1). Top hits are those whose claim 1 most overlaps in technical terminology. Surface independent claim 1 verbatim for each top-5 hit.
Verdict scale
- NOVEL — closest hit has <30% claim-text overlap; clear differentiation possible
- POTENTIALLY NOVEL — 30-60% overlap; differentiation possible but requires careful claim drafting
- NOT NOVEL — >60% overlap; invention as described is anticipated by closest art
DOCX emphasis
- Section 2 (Closest Prior Art): expanded — 8-10 hits with full claim-1 text
- Section 7 (Strategy): claim-differentiation suggestions
- Sections 3 + 5 (Landscape + Geographic): abbreviated
- Mandatory legal disclaimer footer
Strategy 2: Freedom-to-Operate
Question being answered
"If I ship in jurisdiction X, will I get sued for infringement?"
Search emphasis
- Active patents only — expired/abandoned patents can't sue
- Jurisdiction-filtered — FTO only matters where user sells
- Date filter: priority date < today (no pending applications without published claims)
- Independent + dependent claims — both relevant to infringement analysis
Query plan
- Per jurisdiction (Q3): 2-3 queries with jurisdiction filter (US: USPTO; EP: Espacenet; etc.)
- Active-status filter applied to all
- CPC class follow-up after initial hits
- (Optional) assignment chain check for active assignee context
Total: 8-15 sequential queries (scales with # of jurisdictions).
Ranking heuristic
Rank by claim-by-claim infringement risk. For each active patent: which independent claims would the user's product practice? High risk = at least one independent claim covers user's product as designed.
Verdict scale (per jurisdiction)
- CLEAR — no active patents pose infringement risk
- FLAGGED — 1-2 active patents may pose risk; design-around viable
- HIGH RISK — 3+ active patents pose risk; design changes required OR licensing path needed
DOCX emphasis
- Section 6 (FTO Flags): expanded — per-flag risk per jurisdiction
- Section 5 (Geographic Coverage): expanded
- Section 7 (Strategy): design-around hints + jurisdiction strategy
- Mandatory legal disclaimer footer
Strategy 3: Competitive Landscape
Question being answered
"Who else plays in this technology space? What are the trends?"
Search emphasis
- Broader queries on the technology space (NOT the specific invention)
- CPC class identification drives the analysis
- Top filer tally — who files most patents in the space
- 10-year filing trend by year per top-5 filer
Query plan
- 2-3 broad queries on the technology space
- CPC class extraction from top hits
- 1 query per top-5 filer to gauge their portfolio
- (Optional Lens.org) citation graph for foundational patents
Total: 8-10 sequential queries.
Ranking heuristic
Rank by filer count + recency. Top-5 filers + 3 emerging entrants (filers with first patent in last 2 years).
Verdict scale
- CONCENTRATED — top-3 filers own >60% of patents in the space
- COMPETITIVE — top-10 filers own 60-90%; mature competitive market
- EMERGING — long tail of filers; market is still defining itself
DOCX emphasis
- Section 3 (Patent Landscape): expanded — top filers table + 10-yr trend + CPC distribution
- Section 5 (Geographic Coverage): expanded
- Sections 2 + 4 (Closest Art + Citation Graph): abbreviated
- Section 7 (Strategy): who-to-watch list + emerging-entrants signal
- Legal disclaimer optional (lower legal exposure)
Strategy 4: Acquisition Diligence
Question being answered
"Does target company actually own the patents they claim? Is there portfolio depth?"
Search emphasis
- Specific assignee searches — target company + subsidiaries + named inventors
- Assignment chain check — USPTO assignment recordation
- Family resolution — deduplicate same-invention across jurisdictions
- Portfolio scope — are patents in core business areas or peripheral?
Query plan
- 2-3 assignee-name queries (Google Patents + USPTO assignee search)
- Subsidiary searches if user provides org chart
- Inventor searches for key named inventors
- Assignment recordation lookups for ownership verification
- Family resolution across all hits
Total: 6-12 sequential queries.
Ranking heuristic
Group by family. Within family, surface earliest priority. Across families, rank by:
- Citation count (foundational vs niche)
- Filing recency (active R&D vs legacy)
- Claim breadth (broad coverage vs narrow)
Verdict scale
- PORTFOLIO VERIFIED — claimed patents owned, assignment chains clean, no orphans
- PARTIAL VERIFICATION — some claimed patents not found OR assignment chain unclear
- OWNERSHIP RISK — significant claimed patents not owned by target OR major assignment gaps
DOCX emphasis
- Section 3 (Patent Landscape): expanded as portfolio table
- Section 5 (Geographic Coverage): expanded
- Section 7 (Strategy): red flags in portfolio + ownership-verification flags
- Legal disclaimer optional but recommended (M&A context)
Strategy 5: Litigation Prior-Art
Question being answered
"Can I invalidate this specific patent? What art exists before its priority date?"
Search emphasis
- Target patent input required (number)
- Priority date extraction — sets the prior-art cutoff
- Search before priority date in same CPC classes
- Adjacent-claim-language search — art that uses similar claim language
Query plan
- Fetch target patent (extract priority date + claims + CPC classes)
- CPC class queries with date filter (priority < target's priority)
- Keyword queries on independent claim language with date filter
- (Optional Lens.org) forward citations from target's cited art
Total: 5-8 sequential queries.
Ranking heuristic
Rank by knock-out potential — claim-by-claim anticipation/obviousness. Highest rank: art that anticipates ALL elements of target's broadest independent claim.
Verdict scale
- KNOCK-OUT FOUND — art clearly anticipates all elements of broadest claim
- STRONG OBVIOUSNESS COMBINATION — multiple pieces of art combine to cover all elements
- WEAK OBVIOUSNESS — art relevant but anticipation/obviousness argument is uphill
- NO MATERIAL ART FOUND — patent appears strong against this prior-art set
DOCX emphasis
- Section 2 (Closest Prior Art): expanded — ranked knock-out candidates with claim-language overlap
- Section 7 (Strategy): per-claim invalidity analysis
- Sections 3 + 5 (Landscape + Geographic): abbreviated
- Legal disclaimer optional but recommended (litigation context)
Out-of-Scope Topics (Flagged at Intake)
| Topic | Why out of scope | |---|---| | Trademark | Different legal regime, different sources (USPTO TESS not Patent Office) | | Copyright | No formal search system; rights attach automatically | | Trade secret | By definition, not in public records |
If user asks for any of these → halt at intake, recommend appropriate skill or attorney.
Operational Checklist
- [ ] Q2 sub-use-case picked (no "all of them")
- [ ]
scripts/sub_use_case_router.pyreturns query plan + ranking heuristic + DOCX flags - [ ] Search emphasis matches sub-use-case (not generic)
- [ ] Verdict scale per sub-use-case applied
- [ ] DOCX emphasis adjusted (not all 8 sections expanded for every sub-use-case)
- [ ] Legal disclaimer mandatory for novelty + FTO; optional for landscape/diligence/litigation but recommended
Citations (7 sources)
-
MPEP (Manual of Patent Examining Procedure) — USPTO. Source for the legal definitions of novelty (35 USC §102) vs FTO (no explicit USC; case law) vs anticipation/obviousness. The verdict scales follow MPEP terminology.
-
35 USC §102 + §103 — US patent statute. Source for the priority-date-as-cutoff rule for novelty (§102) and the obviousness combination doctrine (§103) that drives litigation prior-art ranking.
-
WIPO Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT) procedural docs. Source for the cross-jurisdiction family discipline. PCT applications generate national-phase entries in many jurisdictions; the family resolver follows WIPO's family-id taxonomy.
-
EPO Guidelines for Examination — European Patent Office. Source for the EP-specific FTO discipline. EP active-status filtering uses EPO's "in force" status field.
-
USPTO Patent Public Search documentation. Source for the USPTO PPS query syntax and assignment-recordation lookup endpoints used in acquisition diligence.
-
Google Patents search documentation + advanced operators. Source for the keyword + CPC class + date filter syntax. Google Patents indexes all PCT national-phase entries plus most jurisdictions' grant data.
-
Lens.org API documentation (https://docs.api.lens.org). Source for the citation-graph queries. Lens.org's citation API exposes forward + backward citations with citation-count thresholds for foundational-patent identification.