templates/expert.md
Lens: Expert Interview
When: interview with an expert/council member to gather judgments, disagreements, and recommendations in a subject area. Not about the expert's personal role, but about their knowledge of the field. Coding unit: an expert's claim with a quote + a note on the degree of confidence and status (fact / assessment / forecast).
Layer 1 — operational (claims + quote + line)
- E1 Expertise profile — what exactly they are competent in, relevant experience, limits of competence (what they consider outside it).
- E2 Key claims — the main statements on the topic, each with a quote; note the type (fact / assessment / forecast).
- E3 Recommendations — specific proposals for action, priority.
- E4 Data and precedents — what they rely on: numbers, cases, sources, analogues.
- E5 Constraints and risks — what they warn about, where they see dangers/pitfalls.
- E6 Open questions — what they don't know themselves / where additional verification is needed.
Layer 2 — analytical (conclusion + quote; CAPS) — to council
- A1 Claim confidence — HIGH / MEDIUM / LOW for each key claim (based on grounding in data vs opinion). (unstable)
- A2 Points of consensus — where it aligns with the mainstream/other experts (if known).
- A3 Points of disagreement — where it diverges, what exactly the dispute is about, whose position is better argued. (unstable)
- A4 Contested/unverifiable statements — what cannot be taken on faith and needs verification.
- A5 Value for the decision — how the claims affect the original decision/strategy.
- A6 Key insight — 1 sentence: the expert claims [X] with confidence [Y], which for the decision means [Z].
Forcing questions
What is this conclusion based on — data or experience? Where could you be wrong? Which of your colleagues would disagree with you and why? What would change your mind? What is contested here?