templates/org-mapping-vmdi.md
Lens: Employee Org-Mapping — VMDI codebook (6 blocks · 40 codes)
When: interview with a VMDI employee following the employee guide. This is a REAL project codebook (museum employees, not a reconstruction). Unit: code. Each code is filled in as quote → What it reveals → Recommendation. Output format per code:
**C3.2 | Incident vs pattern** [category: Incident / Pattern / Not mentioned]
Category: PATTERN
What it reveals: [interpretation — what this code reveals about the system]
_"verbatim quote" (Lxx)_
→ Recommendation: [concrete action; if none — "—"]
Code types: Open-ended text (quote+interpretation), Category (closed choice + quote), List (a set from a reference list + quote). If the topic didn't come up — "Not mentioned".
Δ (1–5) — when comparing AI↔Human: 1 full divergence · 3 partial · 5 full match. Calculated per block (see references/rubric.md).
System-priority rule (Block 3): the same episode recurring across ≥3 employees from different departments = system priority (in synthesis this is triangulation score_insights --k 3 by role).
BLOCK 1. Professional path and dynamics of the relationship with the museum
Goal: context of presence, deliberateness of the choice, internal eNPS.
- C1.1 Circumstances of arrival [open-ended] — when/where they came from, what brought them to this museum specifically; a deliberate choice or chance.
- C1.2 Alternatives at the time of hiring [open-ended] — did they consider other places; why VMDI (subject matter/people/stability/other).
- C1.3 Expectation/reality gap [open-ended] — what turned out unexpected in the first months (+/−).
- C1.4 Motivators and demotivators [list+quote] — Motivators: Mission/Colleagues/Professional growth/Stability/Other · Demotivators: Bureaucracy/Salary/Management/Other.
- C1.5 Internal eNPS [category+quote] — Promoter / Neutral / Detractor / Not mentioned. (unstable cell → council S3)
BLOCK 2. Experience of effective professional work
Goal: the system at its best, reproducibility, bottom-up initiative, cross-department interaction.
- C2.1 Effective case [open-ended] — the project/task of the year they're proud of; the stages.
- C2.2 Source of the initiative [category] — Bottom-up / Top-down / Situational / Not mentioned.
- C2.3 Cross-department interaction [open-ended] — who was involved, how communication was built.
- C2.4 Speed of decisions and approvals [open-ended] — levels of approval; delays even in the best case = a system signal.
- C2.5 Hidden risks / fragility [open-ended] — what could have gone wrong but didn't.
- C2.6 Culture of recognition [category+quote] — Acknowledged by management / By colleagues / By visitors / Not acknowledged / Not mentioned. (unstable → council)
- C2.7 Reproducibility of the result [category] — Systemic process / Personal enthusiasm / Mixed / Not mentioned.
- C2.P Role-specific question [open-ended] — depends on the employee's function; verbatim quote.
BLOCK 3. Experience of operational failures and systemic constraints
Goal: a map of systemic failures. Each episode is a point where a process breaks.
- C3.1 Failure episode [open-ended] — a situation with disproportionate costs.
- C3.2 Incident vs pattern [category] — Incident / Pattern / Not mentioned.
- C3.3 Cause attribution [list] — Competence / Process / Resources / Communication / Mixed / Not mentioned.
- C3.4 Zone of responsibility [open-ended] — who could fix it but doesn't; the "nobody's problem" issue.
- C3.5 Attempts to fix [open-ended] — were any made, the result, where the "wall" is.
- C3.6 Loss estimate [open-ended] — time/financial losses.
- C3.7 Opportunity cost [open-ended] — what they'd do with the freed-up resources.
- C3.P Role-specific question [open-ended] — positioning/reality gap by function.
BLOCK 4. Internal communications and cascading of strategy
Goal: how strategy reaches employees, information gaps, silos, bottom-up initiative.
- C4.1 Channels for receiving information [open-ended] — formal and informal.
- C4.2 Transparency of management [open-ended] — did they learn of a decision after the fact.
- C4.3 Strategy penetration [category+quote] — Articulates / Partially / Doesn't articulate / Not mentioned.
- C4.4 Cross-department silos [list] — with whom it works effectively, with whom it's difficult; specific pairs.
- C4.5 Throughput of bottom-up initiative [category+quote] — Present / Formally present, doesn't work / Absent / Not mentioned.
- C4.6 Employee agency [open-ended] — specific episodes of influencing decisions.
BLOCK 5. Visitor experience through the lens of professional observation
Goal: employees' observations about visitors — an underrated source; patterns outside surveys.
- C5.1 Memorable episode [open-ended] — the most recent interaction with a visitor.
- C5.2 Pattern vs exception [category] — Pattern / Exception / Not mentioned.
- C5.3 Recurring requests / difficulties [list] — friction points along the visitor's path.
- C5.4 Audience segmentation [open-ended] — differences in the audience across areas.
- C5.5 Retention / regular visitors [open-ended] — reason for returning; is it tracked.
- C5.6 Typical visitor + barriers [open-ended] — who comes; what keeps the rest away (structural vs operational barriers).
- C5.7 Priority change in the experience [open-ended] — one aspect from entry to exit.
BLOCK 6. Priorities and direction of development
Goal: priorities and anti-priorities from the inside, intangible needs, forecast.
- C6.1 Metaphor for the mission [open-ended] — an image of the museum in non-official language.
- C6.2 Anchors — what to preserve [list+quote] — what must not be touched even during reforms.
- C6.3 Anti-priorities [list+quote] — which practices to abandon (often more valuable than the list of priorities).
- C6.4 Intangible needs [list] — Authority / Information / Autonomy / Recognition / Other.
- C6.5 Advice to a new director [open-ended] — the most honest answer of the interview.
- C6.6 Forecast in 3 years [category+quote] — Optimism / Anxiety / Apathy / Not mentioned. (unstable → council)
Total 40 codes: B1=5, B2=8, B3=8, B4=6, B5=7, B6=6. Role-specific codes (C2.P, C3.P) are adapted to the respondent's function.